House Hunting: Find a Cottage in the Woods
House Hunting Update: “The Cottage in the Woods”
We’ve been casually house hunting for a few weeks now — driving through neighborhoods, browsing MLS listings, and popping into a few houses when it made sense — and we finally sat down to write about the experience. It’s surprising how much cleaning your own house and scheduling showings can crowd out the time to actually blog about the hunt. That said, we wanted to share one of the first houses that really caught our eye.
One big consideration for us has been how to share this journey while respecting sellers’ privacy. Unlike TV shows where people sign up to have every inch of their home analyzed, these sellers didn’t consent to a public teardown of their houses. So instead of detailed interior photos, we’re sticking to one lightly edited exterior image and an honest description of each home’s pros and cons, along with our thoughts about whether it would work for our family.
Our first feature is the place we started calling “The Cottage in the Woods.” We discovered this property while getting turned around in a nearby neighborhood and instantly fell in love with the outside. It felt so charming from the curb that we almost convinced ourselves we didn’t need to see the interior. That initial curb appeal is a real thing — sometimes a house simply grabs you before you even step inside.

THE STATS:
- Year built: 1953
- House size: 1,905 square feet
- Lot size: 1.4 acres
- Bedrooms: 3
- Bathrooms: 2
THE PROS:
- Charming, older home with plenty of character and room for thoughtful updates
- Extremely private lot tucked into the trees — you enter the property after about 150 feet of wooded drive, which feels secluded and peaceful
- Located in a solid neighborhood with good schools
- Open-feeling living and dining rooms that allow for comfortable daily living and entertaining
THE CONS:
- No primary-suite en-suite bathroom, which is something we hoped to have
- Small, cramped kitchen — roughly half the size of our current kitchen — and not much obvious scope to expand
- Two bedrooms are on the main floor, while the third is in the basement
- The basement ceiling is very low — you need to duck — and the basement bedroom includes a dehumidifier, which felt like a reminder that it’s not ideal as a primary living space
While the exterior and setting were almost storybook-perfect, the interior layout raised practical concerns for us. We love open, airy interiors and the potential to open up a floor plan, but this cottage felt compartmentalized in ways that wouldn’t lend itself easily to those kinds of renovations. The bedroom placement was another sticking point: we prefer keeping bedrooms on or above grade and relatively close together so we can be nearby for Clara and any future children during those early years.
We’re enthusiastic about homes that marry vintage charm with functional flow, but this one felt like it would require settling on some important priorities. Between the small kitchen, the basement bedroom situation, and the low ceiling down below, we ultimately decided that this house would require compromises we weren’t ready to make. It was a bittersweet outcome — the curb appeal and the private, wooded lot made it a real contender in spirit, but not in practicality for our family’s needs.
That said, house hunting is a process, and every tour teaches us something about what we truly want. This cottage helped refine our list: preserve character where possible, but prioritize bedroom layout, a usable kitchen, and main-level sleeping options. We’re excited to keep looking and to share more homes with you as we visit them. Expect more candid notes about what works, what doesn’t, and how we imagine each place could be transformed.
Altered exterior photo taken by us and edited with Photoshop.
P.S. — Don’t forget our big, nerve-wracking appearance on The Nate Show this coming Monday the 25th. Fingers crossed we don’t look like total starstruck geeks.








