Objectales

Popular

Charming Cape Cod Home Steps from Local Shops

featured 30222

With the “Cottage In the Woods” off our list, we turned our attention to another property we toured: a charming Cape Cod-style home conveniently located near shops. We arrived with some hesitancy because the neighborhood was completely new to us, but the house’s faintly urban vibe—sidewalks, nearby stores and that walkable feeling we remembered from our days in NYC—made us want to take a closer look. We were curious to see whether this home could give us the best of both worlds: a quieter county setting with a lively, walkable streetscape.

Exterior of the Cape Cod-style house

THE STATS:

  • Year built: 1945
  • House size: 2,001 square feet
  • Lot size: 0.25 acres
  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 2

THE PROS:

  • Cute, friendly, and walkable neighborhood—stores and everyday conveniences were within easy walking distance (we could even walk to Target!)
  • County schools and taxes with a surprisingly urban feel along the sidewalks and nearby shops
  • Older home with lots of character and clear potential for renovation
  • Gorgeous hardwood floors throughout, which provide a strong design foundation and would be a major selling point after refinishing

THE CONS:

  • Price per square foot was on the high side compared with other options we looked at, which made it less compelling from an investment standpoint
  • The floor plan felt fragmented, with rooms arranged in a way that made the interior feel chopped up and somewhat closed off
  • Primary bedroom on the main floor and the remaining bedrooms upstairs; we prefer bedrooms on the same level for convenience and future-proofing
  • No central air, meaning a significant mechanical upgrade would likely be needed
  • Not as close to family as we’d like, which is an important consideration for us

Once we stepped inside, the house didn’t give us that unmistakable “this is the one” gut reaction we experienced when buying our current home. That immediate connection matters a lot to us, and while the Cape Cod had a lot of appealing features, it ultimately didn’t feel like the right fit. Still, touring it was valuable: it helped clarify what we really want in a walkable neighborhood and confirmed that this kind of area—close to shops, with sidewalks and community feel—resonates with us.

The property’s age and need for updates were both a pro and a con. On the positive side, the vintage details and solid hardwood floors make it a good candidate for tasteful renovation. On the downside, bringing the house up to modern standards would add time and cost: opening the layout for a more cohesive flow, installing central air, and addressing any deferred maintenance would all be necessary investments. Those trade-offs influenced our decision, especially given the higher asking price compared to the other houses we toured.

Another practical consideration was the bedroom arrangement. We want sleeping spaces on the same level for accessibility and convenience, so having the master on the first floor and the other rooms upstairs made the house less appealing. The chopped-up layout also limited how easily we could reconfigure rooms without undertaking major structural changes.

Despite those drawbacks, we liked the exterior charm and the feeling of the neighborhood, which made us want to keep exploring similar two-level homes in Bon Air. We’re expanding our search beyond single-level ranches to include houses with upstairs living so we can compare layouts, light, and circulation across different styles. Bon Air continues to look promising because it offers the blend of community walkability and county living we’re chasing—so we’ll keep an eye out for other Cape Cods and two-story homes that might fit our checklist better.

Exterior photo altered by us for privacy and presentation.

Psst—if you like clever nurseries, we spotted an especially inspired one recently and wrote about it in a Nursery Crashing feature on BabyCenter.