When to Avoid Using Pallets for DIY Projects
How much wood could a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck could chuck wood? I’m no woodchuck expert, but I do know the answer to a smaller question: how many pallet planks could a Petersik pry free if a Petersik could pry free pallet planks? Say that five times fast and you’ll understand why I spent a whole nap wrestling with a pile of pallets.
You may remember the plan for our 12-foot-long DIY console table — the idea was to build a rustic, weathered top out of old pallets that the previous owners left in our yard. After a few soggy days of spring weather, I hauled five waterlogged pallets into my basement workshop to dry so I wouldn’t risk another rainstorm ruining the project.

Once the pallets had dried a bit, I waited for Clara to nap and then started breaking them down. My toolkit was simple: work gloves, a crowbar, a hammer, a handsaw, a flat-head screwdriver and a dust mask (pallet sawdust is not a superfood and we’re trying to keep things safe around the baby).

It turned out to be harder work than I expected. Each plank was nailed or stapled in three places, and each attachment often involved several nails or staples. I tried cutting boards off with a handsaw at first, but because they were secured in the middle as well as the ends, that approach produced short, unusable fragments. Prying the boards off worked better, but it required a lot of effort and often cracked the wood — which ruined long boards we needed for a 140-inch tabletop.

I stuck with it through Clara’s 90-minute nap. By the time she woke up, my nail and staple pile had grown into a small arsenal:

And I had a modest stack of potentially usable boards:

Fourteen salvaged pieces in 90 minutes didn’t sound terrible at first, but when I measured them I realized the widths were all different. For a continuous tabletop made of 4 or 5 planks, that inconsistency would make it very difficult to achieve a uniform 140-inch width — especially since we don’t own a table saw to trim boards down evenly.
I managed to find five boards that matched the exact width I needed (16 7/8 inches across), so theoretically they could form the top.

But only five of the fourteen pieces were actually suitable. That meant in an hour and a half I had about two feet of finished tabletop — at that rate, it would take roughly nine hours to get a full 12-foot top, and that assumes every pallet contained enough perfect pieces (which was unlikely, since I had already stripped one pallet almost completely).
Despite the charm of reclaimed pallet wood, the time, breakage, and inconsistent board widths convinced us to switch plans. Sherry agreed: between the low yield, the effort involved, and growing concerns about chemicals sometimes found in pallets (formaldehyde and other treatments can be a risk), moving to plan B made sense. We still planned to seal anything we used with an eco-friendly finish, but it felt smarter to look for other sources.
Plan B involves searching local suppliers for reclaimed lumber or, if that fails, using store-bought whitewood like we used for the console base. Using consistent, milled boards is less romantic and not free, but it avoids endless prying and gives predictable dimensions. We can always distress the new boards ourselves to get that aged, reclaimed look — honestly, I’m a little excited to experiment with hammers, screws, and other distressing techniques to create character where we want it.

Update: we’ve made solid progress creating a distressed console top without using the pallets. We’ll share full details, photos and videos when we assemble and finish the project.
Meanwhile, Sherry finished staining the exposed sides and small shelves on the console base. She used leftover Minwax Dark Walnut stain and applied an eco-friendly Safecoat Acrlacq topcoat (a water-based, low-VOC finish) to seal the wood. Because much of the console will sit under the tabletop or behind the TV, only the visible end shelves needed staining for now.

Sherry worked in the sunroom to keep fumes away from Clara, applying two coats of stain with a foam brush and wiping off the excess after a few minutes. The next day she added two thin, even coats of Safecoat Acrlacq with a brush to seal the finish and minimize off-gassing. We like that the grain still shows through — it gives the console a warm, authentic and slightly rustic look that will help ground the modern living room.

We’ll be back with a full “console is finally finished” post once we make more headway on the top. In the meantime, I’m enjoying the sight of those freshly stained shelves — Sherry really can make a piece of wood look amazing with just a rag and a little stain.
Pssst — curious about the console’s origins? See our earlier posts about the build for more context. We’ll share even more step-by-step details when the project is complete.








