How to Paint a Chair: Prep, Paint, and Finish
Our $35 secondhand chairs — originally found here — aren’t completely finished yet (picture me tapping my foot while the paint dries), but we wanted to share the makeover progress in real time. First, a quick list of all the colors John and I considered for the office chairs at one point or another:
- emerald green
- turquoise, aqua, or dark teal
- dark gray or light gray
- plum
- navy
- white or light celery
- lime green or “grellow” (green-yellow)
To jog your memory, here are the chairs in the office before paint and new upholstery (photos from a few different angles):


Here’s how our decision-making evolved as we weighed those options over the past month:
- From the dining room doorway, the office is framed by two bright teal bookcases. Choosing turquoise, aqua, or dark teal felt too repetitive from that view.
- After painting the walls gray, we ruled out gray chairs because that felt a little too muted.
- Navy was very close to the chairs’ original color and felt too dark overall.
- White or light celery seemed safe but could skew Palm Beach–y and felt too timid for the energetic palette we wanted.
- Plum risked being as heavy and dark as the original finish.
That left us choosing between emerald green and a limey grellow. I personally liked emerald for a while since it seemed like it might coordinate with the lighter grellow in the kitchen stencil and adjoining walls. But after holding up dozens of emerald swatches, they all read wrong — the undertones clashed with the kitchen and the stencil, and the emeralds leaned cool instead of golden, which made the pairing feel off.
So the winner was… grellow. Not a huge surprise, really. A bold, saturated grellow would reference the lighter grellow on the kitchen walls and the soft yellow-green in the stencil, while also playing nicely with other nearby accents — the indigo light fixture, a teal globe on the file cabinet, the dark teal bookcases in the dining room, and the green runner and curtains. The goal was to pick a color distinctly bolder than the soft kitchen hue so the chairs wouldn’t read like part of a monochrome wash.

We took our color cue from a napkin (yes, really — Sue the Napkin has influenced more of our color choices than you’d expect). We held swatches against the napkin until one matched: Benjamin Moore’s Olive Tree. We taped that swatch to a chair, stepped back, and got heart eyes — it felt just right.
Because the chair seats are woven and wouldn’t take well to brush-applied paint, we planned to use spray paint. Our local Benjamin Moore store can custom-mix spray paint in some locations, so I called to check. The store does offer that service, but they had already closed for the day, so we planned to go the next morning. Then, at Michael’s later that night, we discovered Krylon’s “Ivy Leaf” spray paint, which matched the Olive Tree swatch almost exactly. We grabbed two cans at $5.99 each — a lucky find. (Update: I called Benjamin Moore later and learned their custom spray paint would have required a minimum order of six cans at $7–10 each, so Michael’s was a simpler, cheaper solution.)

At home I removed each seat cushion (held on by four screws) and wiped down the frames with liquid deglosser. We use Next Liquid Deglosser by Crown because it’s non-flammable, biodegradable, and low-VOC. The old paint on these chairs had worn down smoothly, so sanding wasn’t necessary. After cleaning, I set the chairs outside on cardboard to apply spray primer.

I applied a few thin, even coats of primer from about 8–10 inches away, keeping the can moving to prevent drips, and let the primer dry for about 40 minutes. The primer can warned that the topcoat should be applied within one hour or not until 24 hours later; I chose to finish within the hour and applied several ultra-light coats of the grellow spray paint until the color built up evenly.


My favorite spray-painting tips:
- Invest in quality spray paint — skip the $2 cans and spend $6–7 for a smoother finish and better nozzle options. Rust-Oleum’s trigger nozzle sprays thin and even without gunking up your fingers.
- Always keep the can moving; hold it about 8–10 inches from the surface.
- A light mist is better than a heavy, wet coat. Multiple thin coats build coverage without drips.
- Spray paint isn’t VOC-free, so work outdoors with a mask and follow the can’s curing recommendations — usually 24 hours; we often wait longer for extra safety.
- To reduce lingering off-gassing indoors, seal the finish with two thin coats of a low-VOC, non-toxic sealer like Safecoat Acrylacq.
After a few coats the chairs were bright, cheerful, and exactly what we wanted.


I ended up using three cans total, so I made one more trip back to the store. For the seat fabric, I used leftover yardage from a previous dining room curtain project, which coordinated perfectly with the newly grellowed frames.


We debated using that fabric for roman shades in the office, but ultimately decided that upholstering the chairs would be a better balance so the windows wouldn’t feel too matchy. Reupholstering the seats is today’s project; I’ll share details and finished photos in a day or two once everything is dry and reassembled.
We’ll be back with another post later today (a rare 11am update instead of our usual 2pm one), which frees up my afternoon for the upholstery work. Everyone wins.
P.S. We’re also sharing a round-up of kid-friendly DIY project ideas over on BabyCenter — lots of fun projects to add to our someday-to-do list with Clara.








