Transform Your Kitchen with Penny Tile and Open Shelves
We’re finally calling the kitchen “done” — well, almost. The major work is finished and the room looks completely transformed, but there are a few small finishing touches left to complete the makeover.

Remaining tasks include:
- adding decorative molding to the back of the peninsula
- mounting a message center or chalkboard on the side of the pantry
- installing the final floor transitions and finishing the fireplace tile rectangle
- replacing the broken light at the fireplace—probably with a spotlight to wash the wall
- choosing and installing a window treatment above the sink (thinking a colorful Roman shade)
We also hope to refinish the surrounding oak floors someday so they flow seamlessly into the new dark mocha cork in the kitchen, but that’s a long-term plan. For now, the big structural work and most of the cosmetic upgrades are complete. It’s amazing to see how much has changed since we started chipping away at this renovation in October — five months of mostly nights and weekends have made a huge difference.







To make it easier to appreciate the change, here’s a before photo for comparison:

It barely feels like the same room. The previous dark-paneled kitchen we tolerated for almost a year now seems like a distant memory.
Here’s the renovated kitchen shot from the opposite side:


We opened up the wall to create a wide doorway between the kitchen and dining room—here’s a before-and-after from a similar angle:


And another before-and-after from the office doorway leading into the kitchen:


Below are several more perspectives of the finished space so you can get a feel for the layout, materials, and flow:








Styling will always evolve — items on the countertops and shelves will rotate, which is part of the fun. We temporarily placed two 4 x 6 rugs from our previous house just for photos; they’re not permanent. We plan to pick new rugs that better define those areas and feel softer underfoot.

A few details we debated ended up working in context: the silver bar stools complement the stainless appliances and the dark floor, so for now we’ll live with them rather than repainting. We also received a reader-sent mockup of the range hood with a beefed-up neck, and that idea is still tempting — it’s likely to be a future tweak.



We tackled a lot of this renovation ourselves to keep the budget reasonable. Compared with our first kitchen reno — which relied more heavily on professionals and expensive materials — this time we learned more and did more hands-on work. Ways we saved money included:
- handling all drywall and trim work on the dining-room opening ourselves
- relocating the fridge, pantry, and stove to create a better work triangle without hiring movers
- refinishing and repainting the original cabinets rather than replacing them, and reusing the existing sink and faucet
- buying additional base cabinets from a local ReStore to create the peninsula instead of buying new
- reselling old fixtures and appliances to recoup funds
- choosing Corian countertops instead of pricier stone
- buying appliances on sale during tax-free weekends and stacking Energy Star discounts
- building custom elements ourselves, including the cabinet around the fridge, the range hood cover, and open shelving
- installing penny tile backsplash ourselves and taking advantage of sale pricing
- laying clearance cork flooring we purchased and installed ourselves

Below is the actual budget summary we tracked during the renovation. The totals show how a mix of DIY work, smart shopping, and a few tradespeople for specialized jobs can keep costs well below a full professional estimate for a larger-scale remodel.
- New cork floor + underlayment (including laundry room): $848
- All new stainless appliances (after discounts): $2,129
- Doorway opening into dining room (contractor + DIY finish): $790
- Additional base cabinets from ReStore to create peninsula: $88
- Pendant lights over island and sink: $149
- Built-in cabinet around fridge: $90
- All electrical work (local pros over three visits): $711
- Wood filler, primer, and paint for cabinets: $69
- JennAir range hood (Craigslist find): $60
- Materials to hang and frame hood: $115
- Materials for shelves and hanging hardware: $141
- Corian counters in Glacier White: $1,700
- Cabinet hardware and hinges: $173
- Penny tile backsplash: $280
- Four industrial lab stools: $168
- Miscellaneous supplies (fasteners, grout, sealers, etc.): $194
- Items sold on Craigslist to offset costs: +$750
- TOTAL SPENT: $6,955
For context, a fully outsourced renovation of this size could easily run around $30,000. We originally budgeted $10,000, so finishing under $7,000 for a 24′ x 12′ kitchen with new floors, appliances, counters, a tile accent wall, a widened doorway, and custom shelving feels like a big win.

Comparing this to our first kitchen renovation — which cost around $20,500 for a much smaller room and included expensive granite and new cabinets — shows how much you can save by learning skills and doing parts of the job yourself.

This second renovation took roughly 155 hours over five months, mainly nights and weekends around family life. If you have a day job, don’t be discouraged — tackling a major kitchen remodel in small increments is doable and less overwhelming when you divide it into bite-sized projects.

We learned a lot, saved money, and enjoyed the process — even when it disrupted routines. Our advice: keep as many essential appliances working as you can, plan for small inconveniences, and break the renovation into manageable tasks. The result is a kitchen that’s uniquely yours, and the effort really pays off.

Who else is wrapping up a kitchen reno or about to start one? Share your budget-saving tips and DIY wins — this kind of practical advice is invaluable for anyone planning a kitchen makeover on a budget. And a final shout-out to our kids for being so patient through all the hammering and drilling — they were troopers throughout this long project.
To follow the month-by-month progress and detailed posts about this renovation, see our previous monthly updates and project posts.








