Choosing the Right Color for Metal Stools
Choosing the Perfect Color for Our Kitchen Stools
Me + a photo of our kitchen + Photoshop = this post. When we bought our kitchen stools back in December (from a school supply store for $32 each) we knew we might tweak them down the line. Painting, upholstering or staining the seats all crossed our minds, but we wanted to live with the stools for a while so we didn’t make any rash decisions mid-remodel. The plan was simple: let the room come together, use the stools for a bit, and then decide.

They’ve actually worked pretty well as-is. The metal ties into the stainless appliances and gives a subtle industrial feel, and the gray echoes the penny tile wall on the other side of the room. Still, after living with them and weighing options, we finally decided it’s time to paint. Not because we dislike them now, but because a fresh coat of color could take them from good to great.
Our first idea was a dark teal. In the dining room, the back of the built-ins is painted a rich teal that we love seeing through the open layout, so we thought the stools could echo that color without being too matchy.

Because the kitchen opens to the dining room, a touch of that teal on the stools would feel connected and intentional. That said, we wanted to test other options so the stools wouldn’t overwhelm the space.
White was a consideration, but with the cabinets and counters already light and glossy, plain white stools would feel a little flat in the overall palette.

We also tried oil-rubbed bronze (ORB). ORB would coordinate nicely with our pendant hardware and the oven of the room, and from the rendering it provided a good contrast against the white cabinets. I tested a dark charcoal too, but ORB read better in the mock-up. It’s a safe, balanced choice—less exciting, but reliable.

Yellow felt like a fun option because we already have small yellow accents around the kitchen—a jar by the fridge and a planter on the open shelves. The Photoshop version looked intense, so I brought Clara’s yellow highchair into the space to test the color in real life. It turned out surprisingly charming and playful instead of overwhelming.


I also pulled a couple of stools from other rooms—a blue one from HomeGoods and a red one from Joss & Main—to see how those hues felt at the peninsula. All three were appealing in their own ways: the blue picked up shelf accents, the yellow felt sunny and light, and the red was bold and energizing.

That red pushed our curiosity, especially because tomato red is barely used elsewhere in the house and would feel fresh. It could also echo the red tones in the Lady Swimming print near the fridge. To visualize that, I tried another Photoshop mock-up of red metal stools with backs.

One concern with red or deep orange was how it might read against the yellow-green walls and the view across to the fireplace nook, which has a lot more green. To check that, I experimented with leaf green and a deeper emerald tone—both of which could integrate nicely and feel less “fast-food” bright than some warm reds.


We also explored a lighter teal with gray undertones that would sit somewhere between the darker teal and a soft blue-gray—still connected to the built-ins but a touch more muted for the kitchen’s light.

These digital renderings are helpful but imperfect—the way paint reads in real life will change with light and reflections. Still, the exercise was reassuring: our neutral kitchen (white, gray and wood tones) is flexible, and many colors would look great. Ultimately the decision comes down to which color we personally love.
As a small, funny coincidence, after I made one of the mock-ups I walked into the office and found a stack of books that echoed the same color family. It was a reminder that we’re naturally drawn to certain hues for accessories and furniture.


We’ll share the final choice soon—hopefully within a week or two. This mock-up process helped us realize there isn’t one “right” color; there are lots of good options and the best pick will be whichever color makes us smile every time we look at the peninsula. In the meantime, we’d love to hear which color you’d choose—anyone else try Photoshop or try furniture swaps to test color and scale before committing?








