Organize Paint and Pegboards in Your Basement Workshop
Go Navy! Before anyone reads that as taking sides in the long-running Army vs. Navy rivalry, let me assure you I’m neutral—my dad was actually in the Army. I’m not trying to stir up trouble. This post is about the basement, and since we’re on a flight I got an early start writing—so let’s pick up where we left off: this hot mess of a shelf.

For nearly two years this shelf has been the catch-all for paint cans and paint-can-shaped things—boxes that still needed unpacking after our move, quarantine-era clutter, and a general lack of organization. Time to fix that.

I started by clearing everything off the shelves. That gave me elbow room to dust and to sort: what belonged on the shelf (actual paint) and what didn’t (empty boxes and packing). Those extra boxes were broken down and recycled, which already made the space feel calmer.

About 30 minutes later things were looking much better—already more functional and less haphazard.

I moved non-paint items like grout and polymeric sand to other shelves under the workbench so this zone could become paint-only (plus a little stain and primer). The left side is exclusively leftover paint from shoots and projects—mostly quarts and tester cans.

Small organizing tip: to create a tiered display so you can see labels easily, I placed a scrap piece of 2×6 under the front row of cans. It’s a cheap trick that really improves visibility. You can see the tiered effect more clearly in the spray paint shot below—yes, we have nearly every color of the rainbow. Some of that comes from book projects, some from general creative impulse.

This paint setup is simpler than the system we used in our last basement, where we repackaged and labeled every leftover can. That approach was impressively organized but turned out to be high-maintenance when new paint was purchased. So this time I kept it straightforward: group by type and size, keep cans accessible, and accept a little imperfection. Still, seeing the old, hyper-organized photos makes me nostalgic for that level of detail.
Once the shelf was under control, I decided to use some leftover paint on another project: the pegboard above the work surface. Before painting, I dressed up the pegboard with a simple trim using a few scraps and about $10 of new supplies.

A frame helps the pegboard look more intentional—those neatly hung tools are like a practical, nerdy work of art. I only framed three sides because one edge sits directly on the workbench and the overlapping yardstick made the fourth side unnecessary.


With the frames nailed on, I stripped the tools off the pegboard and laid them out roughly where they’d hang so I could decide on the paint plan. I wanted to see how the tools looked before painting the background, in case I wanted to try a partial pattern or an accent instead of painting the whole board.

We chose a leftover quart of Hale Navy by Benjamin Moore—a deep, muted navy we’d used before and loved. I painted the board with a small foam roller in thin coats so the peg holes wouldn’t clog. One coat looked promising, and two thin coats gave an even finish without gumming the holes (some holes were already partially clogged with previous white paint, but they’re still usable).


After two coats, both boards looked consistently navy in person, even though uneven lighting in the room made them appear different shades in photos. Painting the frames the same color toned down contrast and gave the pegboards a slightly more refined look—yes, a sophisticated basement pegboard is a thing now.

Once the paint dried, the tools went back up. The whole upgrade cost roughly $15 for trim (if you don’t have scrap wood) and about $15 for a quart of paint if you need one—small investments for a lot of improvement in workspace organization and appearance.

And just like that, I fell for pegboards all over again. Adding paint and trim is one of those small touches that makes a space feel cared for and more like ours rather than the previous owner’s. It nudges a room from functional to personal.

Next up: I’m thinking of staining some of the wood in the room to add contrast and depth. Photoshop mockups make it look easy—real-life staining will be more work—but it should freshen the space nicely. I’ll keep you posted on that project.


What are you working on lately? Any basement or garage upgrades in progress? Are you falling in love with pegboards too, or do we need a support group for people with too many paint cans? I’m curious—share your projects and tips.








