Build a Fireplace Mantel: DIY Step-by-Step Guide
Ready for the next stage of the fireplace transformation? Good—there’s been a lot of progress. Previously we’d tiled the hearth and part of the surround with marble subway tile.

That tile work was the more straightforward part. The next phase—building out the rest of the frame—required quite a few additional materials and a bit more planning.

We chose MDF for the frame because it’s lighter, smoother, and more affordable than solid wood. The panel we used was a 4 ft × 8 ft sheet that cost just under $35, and fortunately one sheet provided all the pieces we needed.
The first two pieces we built were the vertical sides that sit on the floor and extend up to the mantel.

I cut the MDF to size and joined the two pieces at right angles using a Kreg Jig and wood glue for extra strength.

The nail gun quickly became a favorite because it’s so much faster than drilling and screwing everything. Still, since nails aren’t as secure long-term as screws, I used wood glue as backup wherever possible.

To join the two side pieces, I cut a middle span on the table saw and fastened the three parts together using a couple of scrap 1 × 2″ boards for reinforcement.

If that previous photo was a little unclear, here’s the frame placed around the original brick fireplace so you can see how it all fits.

From above you can see the MDF frame sits snugly around the old brick, which, as it turned out, looked pretty rough once the old mantel was removed.

Because the brick flared under the mantel and tapered toward the floor, there was a small gap between the MDF and the tile in a few places. We filled those gaps with thin strips of MDF so the surround would sit balanced and flush when viewed from the side.

Here’s the frame from the front so the layout is easier to visualize.

It was already fairly stable, but we didn’t rely on balance alone. We drove several masonry screws through the top and sides and ran a bead of construction adhesive where the MDF met the brick to make sure the frame wouldn’t move.

The next step was installing the mantel. The original plan had been to attach the mantel directly to the brick, but the brick wasn’t level and sloped away from the wall, so that approach wouldn’t have worked. Instead we cut more MDF and added a flat top to the frame, securing it with glue and nails.

We built a new mantel top from a 1 × 10 board and framed the visible edges with 1 × 2 pine strips so no raw edges would show. We also used a few strips of leftover lattice from a previous project to raise the mantel slightly so it matched the old height and covered the unpainted paneling behind it. Keeping the mantel at the same height preserved the proportions we liked while fixing the hearth and side profile issues.

After the mantel was secured, we added crown molding underneath to give it more presence. Because the crown needed to sit flush with the decorative boxes we planned to add, we first attached a 1 × 3 board to bump the crown out to the correct depth.

The 1 × 3 allowed an inch of backing for the crown while providing the correct top surface for some of the 1 × 2 box trim to sit against. My wife handled much of the nailing—she’s surprisingly good with the gun.

With the mantel in place it already felt more finished, but the flat-front look was a little too modern for the rest of our kitchen. To match the more traditional cabinet style across the room, we added baseboard and framed the surround with 1 × 2 trim to create simple decorative boxes.

We set the baseboard off from the MDF with scrap 1 × 2 backing so it wouldn’t sit flush against the surface and would align with the box trim.

Then we added vertical 1 × 2 strips, followed by horizontal pieces between them to form the rectangular boxes that give the surround its character.

To avoid long, skinny rectangles on either side, we added another trim piece where the vertical posts meet the middle span; it helped break up the surfaces and balance the overall design.

The trim work moved quickly, so we even had time to caulk some seams before our little one woke up and started asking questions about what we were building.

There’s still work to do: priming and painting, finishing the bottom trim where tile meets the cork floor, and adding quarter round where the baseboard meets the floor. Once those loose ends are tied up the surround will look much more polished.

Even unpainted, we’re thrilled with how the fireplace makeover is shaping up. For comparison, here’s where we started before the new surround and mantel went in:

Give us another day or two to finish the paint and final trim, and we’ll return with the completed fireplace, a full budget breakdown, and a bunch of final photos showing the transformation from start to finish.








