Objectales

Popular

DIY Guide: Remove Scalloped Porch Trim and Repair Columns

featured 57188

Since we moved in back in 2010, we’ve talked about simplifying the porch and giving the columns a more substantial, updated look. Now that spring has finally arrived (after a long winter), we were ready to start a porch renovation project: removing the scalloped header and wrapping the columns to create a cleaner, chunkier appearance.

img 57188 1

Most of the ranch houses in our neighborhood have either thick square columns or a more formal colonial style. Our home came with the latter and a curved scalloped header that didn’t match our aesthetic. We wanted to replace that decorative curve with a straight, clean-lined header and wrap the existing columns to achieve the modern, chunky look found on other homes nearby.

img 57188 2

Sherry had tackled scallops on our first house years ago, and we knew the process could be messy and time-consuming—but it can also deliver a dramatic update. This porch proved to be a different kind of challenge: more wood trim, no metal flashing to fight, and taller columns to alter. Before starting demolition we ran a utility knife along the seams to encourage the paint to break cleanly where we wanted it to. That step helps prevent uncontrolled peeling and minimizes damage when removing painted trim that’s been layered over for years.

img 57188 4

I expected demolition to be a slog after hearing the old horror stories, so I was pleasantly surprised when a few knocks with a rubber mallet loosened the scalloped header. Once it gave, a crowbar pried it away cleanly and quickly. With the curved trim removed the porch already looked more streamlined, even before we started building the new header and column boxes.

img 57188 5

The exposed area wasn’t glamorous—there were gaps and rough edges—but the hard part was done, and we could move on to rebuilding a simple, straight header and boxing out the columns for a solid 8×8 look.

img 57188 6

To install the new header we nailed and glued a pre-primed piece of 1×3 pine where the scallops had been. That gave us a crisp, straight edge across the porch and a clean starting point for the column work.

img 57188 9

Next came the most visually transformative step: boxing out the columns. Rather than remove the existing posts, we wrapped them in pre-primed pine boards to create the chunky square profile we wanted. This approach is faster, less disruptive, and cost-effective compared with replacing posts entirely.

img 57188 10

Our columns were just a few inches shy of eight feet, so we trimmed boards to the right length with a circular saw. Two sides of each column were covered with 1×6 boards; fortunately the original post width matched a 1×6, so only the lengths needed trimming. We glued the boards with heavy-duty wood glue and secured them with 2″ nails at the top and bottom, then added screws for extra long-term strength.

img 57188 11

Since covering two sides increased the width, the remaining two sides required 1×8 boards. Although nominally labeled 8″, these boards run closer to 7.5″ in actual width, so once all four sides were combined the finished column ends up roughly 7.5″ square—close to the classic 8×8 appearance many homeowners prefer.

img 57188 12

Two tools made the job much easier: our nail gun and an extra pair of hands. Wrapping columns is definitely easier and faster as a two-person project—one person holds boards in place while the other secures them—but once the pieces were tacked and screwed the progress was swift. We paused a bit when Clara came home, but the transformation was already obvious and gave us great momentum for the next steps.

img 57188 13

We do plan to beef up the header slightly under the roofline so it visually balances the new, wider columns. Once that’s done we’ll caulk all seams to prevent moisture intrusion, and then paint everything for a seamless, finished look.

img 57188 15

Remaining tasks:

  • Finish boxing in the last column
  • Add a wider header trim to balance the new column proportions
  • Caulk all seams to protect the wood from moisture
  • Prime and paint the entire porch for a cohesive finish

We’ll share before-and-after photos once the final touches are complete. In the meantime, Sherry made a quick craft for Clara that’s been popular around here—one of those small DIY projects that keep kids busy while the big projects take shape.

img 57188 17

Anyone else turning their attention to outdoor projects? Whether you’re planning a front porch renovation, new flower beds, a patio refresh, or simple landscaping updates like fresh mulch, this is a great time of year to tackle curb appeal and exterior maintenance. If you’re wrapping columns or building a new header, prepping seams, using pre-primed boards, and a two-person workflow will make the job much easier—and more satisfying—when it’s done.