Did We Profit from Selling Our Second Home?
Did We Make a Profit Selling Our House Again?
We answered this question after selling our first home, and now we’re revisiting it with the sale of our second house. The timing and circumstances were more favorable this time: we sold in a stronger market and didn’t have to invest in large, costly structural replacements like a new roof or windows. That combination helped the numbers look better.

In short, we sold this house for $23,000 more than we paid for it in 2010. After accounting for the improvements we made that stayed with the house, our best estimate is that we spent about $14,511 on permanent upgrades. Subtracting that investment from the sale gain leaves an estimated net improvement profit of roughly $8,500. Below is a breakdown of the major improvement costs that contributed to the home’s resale value:
- Kitchen renovation (appliances, new flooring, backsplash, lighting, countertops, opening a wall, etc.): $6,955
- Deck construction, staining and sealing: $1,783
- New patio installation: $1,252
- Custom built-in desk in the office (conveyed with the house): $124
- Laundry appliances and built-in shelving: $712
- Hall bathroom update: $168
- Guest bathroom refresh: $51
- Crown molding added throughout the house: $218
- Fireplace update with new tile and mantel: $147
- Board-and-batten trim in the hallway: $57
- Pergola added over the carport: $214
- Porch column refresh: $198
- Window boxes and plants: $132
- Paint and stain for every room, built-ins, and outdoor areas (doesn’t include furniture finishes that moved with us): $800
- Landscaping, lighting, curtains, and other miscellaneous items that remain with the house (including new border tile and a toilet in the main bath): $1,700
- Total: $14,511*
*Some listed project totals included items we kept, such as art or accessories, so this tally is an estimate rather than an exact accounting.

Even allowing for approximate numbers, we’re grateful to have increased the house’s value over a relatively short period. Compared to our first house—where market timing left us with almost no gain—this outcome felt like a small victory. At closing we paid a 3% fee to cover the buyer’s agent commission; we were also thankful we didn’t have to pay a seller’s agent fee, which would have been larger.
When the dust settled, we likely broke about even on the home after counting purchase price, improvement costs, commissions, and other selling expenses. We aren’t flipping houses for profit, but we are passionate about creating a comfortable, functional space. The real win for us wasn’t turning a massive profit—it was being able to roll the equity we built across seven years of mortgage payments on our first two homes into our next purchase, which substantially reduced our new mortgage balance.

As we plan for the new house, built-ins are already on the list. They offer practical storage and a tailored look, and in our experience they can be an affordable value-add—both of the built-ins we installed were under $125 each. Kitchens, bathrooms, and additional outdoor living space (decks, patios) often deliver the strongest resale returns, but small, well-executed touches like built-ins can boost functionality and buyer appeal without breaking the bank.
Have you tracked what you spent on improvements compared to what you recouped at sale? Do you find that kitchens, bathrooms, and outdoor square footage added the most value in your experience? We’d love to hear whether smaller features—built-in storage, shelving, or custom trim—made a difference for you when selling.








