Replacing an Old Furnace and Installing a New Roof: Cost Guide
Replacing Our Roof and Furnace: What We Did—and What We Learned
When we bought our house, two immediate problems needed attention:
- The first-floor furnace was decades old and so poorly maintained we weren’t sure it would run.
- The 32-year-old roof was at the end of its life and had a hole that leaked into the attic whenever it rained.

Fortunately, both issues were disclosed before we closed, and we negotiated a credit at closing to help cover the cost of repairs. A new roof and a replacement furnace are not inexpensive, so getting some money back at closing made those immediate updates less painful. While we were on a book tour, we juggled phone calls with roofers and HVAC companies between events and flights, and somehow managed to coordinate the work so the house could be made safe and weather-tight quickly.

The roof work revealed a surprising amount of rot. In some areas the shingles and the plywood beneath had to be removed and replaced entirely.

It looked worse before it got better.

Clara, however, didn’t seem phased by the two-foot piles of old roofing material strewn around the property. She inspected everything like a pro.

After the crew finished the work, the improvement was dramatic.

For the roofer, we chose the same local, fully insured family-owned company we’d used on our first house—professionals with a long track record in the area. We still obtained three estimates to compare pricing and scope, but the roofer we already trusted offered the best combination of price, experience, and reliability.
When deciding on materials, we drove around the neighborhood looking at homes we admired to see which roofs complemented the style of our brick colonial. We settled on 50-year dimensional shingles with large slate-like shapes that felt in scale with the house. You can see the look best on the lower roof over the garage in this photo:

Up close, the tiles have a chunky, square-ish appearance. We used GAF Camelot II in Antique Slate, a product often described as a 50-year roof with a lifetime warranty option. It gives the house a substantial, slate-like appearance that suits the period architecture.

While the new roof felt like a long-term fix and relieved the immediate worry about attic leaks and potential mold, the furnace remained a persistent issue. The old unit—original to the house at about 32 years—had apparently never been properly cleaned or maintained. At one point we even smelled gas in the garage, which was frightening and prompted multiple service calls.

Because the furnace was so old, finding replacement parts was difficult. After several service attempts and mounting concern about safety, we received an unexpected and welcome call from our home warranty provider: they approved a brand new Goodman furnace, including installation and some new ductwork, at no additional cost to us. We had purchased a one-year home warranty at closing—about $500—to cover major issues during that initial ownership period, and that investment paid off in a big way. When the crew arrived with the new 5K furnace fully installed, the decision to buy the warranty felt like the best money we’d spent on the house.

These two updates—roof replacement and furnace replacement—were urgent and non-negotiable, so we prioritized them and were relieved to have them behind us. Coordinating service while touring and managing two homes at once was challenging; at one point my in-laws had to meet a technician at the new house because we were returning from a tour stop. Still, knocking these major items off the list early provided peace of mind and allowed us to focus on other projects.
One practical takeaway: if you’re buying a home, consider whether a short-term home warranty is worth the cost for the peace of mind it can provide. Also, when choosing materials like roofing, a neighborhood “crawl” to see what works visually can be a simple and effective way to determine the right aesthetic for your home.
Update: People’s experiences with home warranties vary. Many readers reported that a warranty helped them avoid large expenses, while others shared frustrations. Results seem to depend on the provider, region, and specific circumstances, so it’s worth researching options thoroughly before purchasing.








