Objectales

Popular

Choosing New Siding Color and Updating Your Exterior Trim

featured 59370

When we moved into this house we knew there were four major issues to address: the roof and furnace, a few problematic trees, and sections of siding and trim that were rotting and needed replacement along with a full exterior paint job. The interior already had plenty of blue and mauve trim to contend with, and the outside trim wasn’t looking great either. Still, knowing these fixes were coming made them less of a surprise. Here’s how we tackled the siding, trim, and paint—what we learned about color selection, rot repair, and hiring professionals for exterior house painting and siding replacement.

img 59370 1

Some areas of the siding had deteriorated enough to create entry points for wildlife. That hole shown was large enough for a bat or a mouse to get in, which was gross but an important reminder that any visibly rotten sections have to be cut out and replaced to keep pests and moisture out.

img 59370 2

Several pieces of wood trim and siding were beyond salvaging and required full replacement. The rest needed thorough cleaning, scraping, priming, and two fresh coats of paint to protect it from future rot. Because much of the work was high off the ground and the rot was widespread, we decided this was a job for professionals. We collected four estimates and chose a local chain, Certa Pro Painters, who came highly recommended by a neighbor and a friend. They were flexible on scope, which let us save about $1,000 by agreeing to DIY a few simpler areas ourselves.

Next came color selection. We wanted two complementary colors—one for the siding and a separate one for the trim—to add dimension to the brick colonial. After walking the neighborhood and comparing similar homes, we settled on a putty-toned siding color (a balanced gray-brown that echoes the brick) and a crisp white for the trim that wasn’t too yellow or too blue.

img 59370 3

Quick tip we learned the hard way: swatches can look much lighter on the house than expected once the paint is up. We initially chose a lighter putty swatch, then realized as the first coat went on that a slightly darker shade would have more presence next to the brick. Thankfully, the painters were able to switch to the darker tone for the second coat, and it provided excellent coverage and the richer look we wanted.

img 59370 4

The final result is a well-balanced exterior: the deeper putty siding ties into the brick without competing with it, and the white trim pops cleanly against both. The darker siding tone gave the house more visual weight and eliminated the washed-out feel the lighter choice produced.

Watching the process was fascinating. The crew power-washed the entire house first, then scraped and primed raw wood before painting. They replaced any rotten sections, and in total they cut out and repaired about 20 pieces of siding and trim. The full timeline was one day of power washing, two days of rot repairs and scraping, and two days of priming and painting. For paint they used Duration by Sherwin Williams, which the crew recommended for exterior durability and coverage. We used Snowbound for the white trim and Anonymous for the putty siding.

img 59370 5

The new paint and the recently replaced roof both make a big difference from the curb. Even small details like the white trim around windows and the fresh porch railing contribute to a cleaner, more cohesive appearance. Every time we pull up to the house we still pause for a moment—our eyes are getting used to the updated look.

img 59370 6

Here’s the backyard before—notice how the top-right portion of siding looked lighter and visually unbalanced. After painting the siding in the darker putty tone the whole rear elevation feels more integrated and less like an afterthought. The sunroom, which had been all cream, now feels crisper and better tied into the rest of the house thanks to the contrast between the dark storm windows, brick, and new siding color.

img 59370 7

Cost for exterior paint and rot repair varies by region and by how much damage you have, but for us the repairs ran about $1,000 and scraping and painting totaled a little over $2,000. We also received a 10% discount through a local membership perk. Because the project was expensive, we negotiated to handle a few straightforward areas ourselves—garage doors, the interior of the sunroom (walls, trim, ceiling), and the front door and sidelights—which knocked roughly $1,000 off the final bill and gave us time to plan those final color choices. I’m especially excited to pick a bold new front door color; every swatch is still in play.

img 59370 17

Home improvement can be expensive—and sometimes inconvenient—but seeing the finished exterior transform the house makes it worth it. The repaint and repairs protect the structure and instantly improve curb appeal, proving that good siding repair and professional exterior painting are investments that pay off visually and structurally.