Front-Load vs Top-Load Washing Machines: Pros and Cons
Our new washer and dryer have finally arrived, and I wanted to share how the installation went, what we did with the flooring underneath, and how the machines are performing so far. Over the years we’ve lived with several laundry setups: front-loaders with a countertop in our first house, stacked front-loaders with cubbies in our second, and top-loaders with cabinetry in this house. Each arrangement has offered different advantages and trade-offs.

Front-loaders with a counter were great for folding and sorting, but the counter often turned into a catch-all for clutter. Stacked front-loaders freed up floor space and provided cubby storage that tended not to get as messy, though bending and lifting could be awkward. Top-loaders remove the need to bend as much and leave the top of the dryer as a usable surface for baskets or air-drying, while upper cabinets keep supplies tucked out of sight and easy to access.

Here are the new machines sitting in the laundry nook. We haven’t finished that little corner yet, but the new units already feel like an upgrade.

Before installation we prepped the area under the washer and dryer. The previous owner had left a pan under the washer and scraps of carpet under the dryer, so once the old appliances were out we quickly removed the carpet and decided to install 3/4″ plywood to match the depth of our hardwood floors. The plywood gives the exposed subfloor a much more finished look and creates a firmer base for the appliances. We stained the boards with a Dark Walnut coat and sealed them with three coats of SafeCoat Acrylacq.

We had used plywood under our previous washer and dryer as well because the added reinforcement can be easier on the machines and may extend their life. When the delivery crew removed the old units, we hurriedly pulled up the carpet and underlayment. The carpet had been fastened down tightly, so John had to work quickly to scrape up staples before the new appliances arrived. Once the plywood boards—which we stained and sealed ahead of time—were slid into place, the change looked seamless.


There is a small gap left where trim juts out too far for a perfectly flush fit; we’ll cut one more piece of plywood, stain it to match, and slide it into place. We also plan to replace the existing blue folding doors with white ones, so a subtle flooring transition in the nook makes sense until we fully renovate the space.

Because these machines live on the second floor, leak protection was a priority. We set the washer in a plastic catch basin and upgraded the supply lines to reinforced steel instead of the thin plastic lines. During installation a small leak showed up at the connection, but the installer tightened the fitting and resolved it immediately. The takeaway: always check water lines and connections during delivery and setup.

On the performance side, we really like the dryer. It’s quieter, has a larger capacity, and uses a heat sensor to avoid over-drying—our old dryer tended to shrink items by running too hot. The new dryer also uses a pleasant chime to signal the end of a cycle instead of an aggressive buzz. The washer’s digital display is easy to read and shows remaining cycle time, and its tub holds much more laundry than our previous machine.


However, we did run into an unexpected hiccup: the washer began making a loud grinding noise during the agitator cycle on our first full load. The delivery team had tested for leaks but didn’t run a full cycle, which is understandable. Home Depot directed us to the manufacturer for service, and Maytag scheduled a technician for a week later—far longer than we were comfortable waiting. After explaining the urgency, Home Depot agreed to take the machine back and deliver a replacement within a few days. While the service experience had a bump, we appreciated Home Depot’s responsiveness in resolving the issue more quickly.
For now we’re pleased with the dryer and the new flooring under the machines, and we’re hopeful the replacement washer will arrive trouble-free. We’re also glad both appliances come with a one-year warranty for added peace of mind. Has anyone else experienced delivery or appliance issues? It’s reassuring to know how retailers and manufacturers handle repairs or replacements when problems pop up.
*************************************
Sidenote: We’ll be at the Richmond Home & Garden Show this weekend, speaking at 2pm on Saturday and Sunday with a book signing after Saturday’s talk. It was a surprise to see our faces on a highway billboard—equal parts thrilling and terrifying!

Seeing your own face that large definitely makes you scream out of pure shock. It was an unforgettable moment.








