How to Choose the Right Exterior House Paint Color
When we last shared an update on the Habitat for Humanity showhouse we’re helping with (details previously posted here and here), the exterior was nearly finished and simply waiting on paint. Then an unusual three-week stretch of snow delayed things, which gave us time to finalize fixtures, tile, and cabinetry. Now that the weather has cooperated, we can finally reveal our exterior color choice—and yes, we’re pretty excited about it.
From the start, we knew we wanted the house to sit in the navy family, balanced with crisp light trim and some rustic accents—think chunky wood porch beams and stone around the foundation. The builder liked that direction, so our job was to pick the exact navy shade for his crew to paint. We began by bringing a stack of swatches down to the site and comparing them against different planes of the house during natural daylight. Seeing colors in place helped us evaluate undertones and how each swatch read next to the roof and trim. Here are the nine swatches we tested:

Some options were eliminated right away: Gravel Gray and Polo Blue read almost black in person, Westcott Navy skewed too gray, and Van Deusen Blue appeared lighter than expected. After narrowing things down, three contenders remained:

Hale Navy had charcoal undertones, Gentleman’s Gray felt like a straightforward classic navy, and Newburg Green was a touch lighter with a subtle green cast. The three gave us a useful range instead of three nearly identical navies, and we liked all of them enough to proceed to full test pots.
We bought sample quarts and brushed each color directly onto the siding so we could see them at scale. Clara helped mix the paint:

After applying two coats and allowing proper drying time, the differences became clearer: Hale Navy and Gentleman’s Gray read darker and more intense, while Newburg Green felt less “midnight,” a touch more casual and inviting. The iPhone photos below don’t capture all the nuances we observed in person, but they give a general idea of what we saw on site.

Clara even joined in for the final coat—start them young, right?

In person, Newburg Green simply felt friendlier and less formal than the other two. We also liked the contrast it provided with the roof—Hale Navy and Gentleman’s Gray might have blended in too much with the shingles because of their depth and gray undertones.

With that, Newburg Green became our choice. For the trim we selected Steam, a soft white that reads clean without being harsh. It gives a crisp edge to the house while remaining warm and approachable.

Here she is, freshly painted and looking lovely. We’re pleased with how Newburg Green plays off the roof tone and Steam trim. Those round windows in the gables are such a sweet architectural detail, and the paint really highlights the thick trim and other charming features. There are still finishing touches left—chunky porch columns will be added on top of the stone pillars and the exposed wood will be sealed, deepening its warm, rustic color.

Landscaping will also make a big difference, softening the house into its site and helping it feel fully integrated with the surroundings instead of “the house that sprang up overnight.”
Now let’s talk about the front door. It arrived in a neutral factory finish that can’t be stained, so we experimented with a wide range of painted options in Photoshop to visualize how different tones would work against the Newburg Green and Steam trim. We tested more than two dozen variations and narrowed the field down to six finalists that complemented the exterior elements without overwhelming them. Photoshop is only a guide—the actual painted door will have more depth and texture than these mockups suggest.

Here’s a closer look at the contenders. First is a greeny blue-gray (we’re calling it Blue Steel), which reads as a subtle, slightly muted complement to the siding.

We also considered a deep chocolate tone—a rich, grounded option that plays off the natural timber and stone.

A classic red was another possibility, for a nautical, all-American accent that adds bold contrast.

We also explored a rich plum—a moody, elegant choice that reads differently depending on light and angle.

Rust tones were considered as well, which would echo the warm notes in the stone and the finished porch beams once they’re sealed.

Finally, a putty shade that ties into the roof and stone colors presented a subdued, cohesive option.

We’d love your input on the door color. We can’t finalize it until the porch beams are installed and sealed—those finishes will influence how the door reads—but your feedback will help narrow our choice.
VOTING ON THIS POLL HAS CLOSED

Inside the house, tile and hardwoods are being installed and we’ve begun sourcing furniture and rugs while finalizing interior paint selections. We’ll share those updates and room progress soon—hopefully within the next week or two.
Psst – Want to see the finished showhouse? View our full showhouse tour for final room photos, the floor plan, budget information, a video walkthrough, and the pieces we used in the finished rooms.








