Objectales

Popular

5 Kitchen Remodel Mistakes We Made: Avoid These Pitfalls

featured 79144

There are countless decisions, measurements, and plan changes that go into a kitchen remodel. It’s unrealistic to expect everything to go perfectly from start to finish — you’ll almost certainly hit a few speed bumps and need to course-correct. Our project was no different (you may have heard about our giant tile miscalculation on our podcast), so here’s a clear recap of five mistakes we made, how we fixed them, and what we learned. If you’re planning a kitchen renovation, these are the kinds of issues to watch for so you can avoid the same headaches.

five-kitchen-renovation-mistakes-to-avoid-tips

Mistake #1: An Almost Off-Center Doorway

During framing we noticed a cluster of studs that looked odd. A tape measure revealed the new opening between the kitchen and living room was nearly three inches closer to one side than intended. It was a small difference, but it would have made the built-in bookcases on the other side look noticeably unbalanced, with much more filler showing around one cabinet than the other. We corrected it before finishing, and I’m so glad we did — a few inches can make a big visual difference in symmetry.

kitchen-mistakes-off-center-doorway

Mistake #2: Fridge Placement That Felt Wrong

On paper our fridge placement made sense: a large appliance next to the door with uninterrupted pantry cabinets on the back wall. In real life, however, the fridge’s height sat awkwardly next to the door and looked visually out of sync with the surrounding cabinets. Sherry mocked up an alternate layout and asked the installers if the pantry cabinet could be moved between the fridge and the door. They agreed and the swap only took minutes — but the improved balance was immediate. Lesson: if something looks off, speak up. Small changes during install are often much easier than living with a regret.

kitchen-mistakes-fridge-wrong

Mistake #3: Pendant Lights That Were Too Delicate

We initially selected simple glass globe pendants because they were classic and affordable. Once installed, though, they looked too delicate above our chunky island — they felt pinheaded and unsubstantial from the living room at night. After a long search we designed a pendant with a larger profile while keeping the polished-nickel stem we liked. The new fixtures have the visual weight the island needed and now feel like one of the room’s defining features. Takeaway: scale matters. Lighting should feel proportionate to the furniture and architecture around it.

kitchen-mistakes-old-pendant-lights

Mistake #4: Stools That Didn’t Fit

We fell in love with a set of stools that looked perfect in mood boards, and we paid extra for “white glove” delivery. When they were finally brought in we discovered their armrests were too tall to tuck under a standard-height counter — something we had somehow overlooked. We returned them for a full refund and eventually found more appropriate stools that matched the look and fit the space. Moral: always measure fully assembled furniture against final countertop heights, not just the listed “counter-height” label.

kitchen-mistakes-too-tall-stool

Mistake #5: Repainting — Twice

We painted the room Simply White by Benjamin Moore early in the project to unify the space while other decisions were pending. As the room progressed, that bright white read too stark and unfinished. The backsplash and tile choices pushed us toward a softer neutral, so we repainted the walls Irish Mist by Behr, a light gray that creates subtle contrast with trim and cabinetry while echoing tones in the tile. Separately, the garage door started as a stock white; after testing several swatches we landed on a muted blue that reads well in that nook and complements the tile without competing with it. Repainting added time, but the final colors helped the whole space feel cohesive.

kitche-demo-flooring-in

Bonus: Three Mistakes We Avoided

Beyond the fixes above, here are three planning choices we intentionally handled well so they didn’t become regrets.

Bonus Tip #1: Leave Space for Tile

We wanted the backsplash tile to run to the ceiling and wrap around the windows. That required leaving enough space at each side of the windows so the tile would read as a continuous expanse rather than two separate stripes. We planned a 7″ gap at each side of the windows, which allowed visible tile without custom cabinet widths. The result looks intentional and polished.

kitchen-remodel-final-counter-depth-fridge-450

Bonus Tip #2: Try Horizontal Outlets

Instead of the usual vertically oriented outlets placed higher on the backsplash, we turned outlets on their side and lowered them closer to the countertop. This makes them easier to conceal when not in use and visually less disruptive to a large tile field. It’s a small detail that preserves the tile’s visual flow and reduces “eyesore” interruptions.

kitchen-remodel-final-sideways-switches

Bonus Tip #3: Don’t Settle for the Default

We worked with a local cabinet company but didn’t accept the stock hood cover they showed in the rendering; it pinched at the top and would have made the adjacent cabinets look narrower. With our cabinet installer’s help we ordered a different vent cover from another source and painted it to match the cabinets. Most cabinet makers supply matching touch-up paint, so mixing and matching select pieces is often an easy way to improve the overall design without custom cabinet costs.

mistakes-quality-hood

There are plenty of other small decisions that could have become regrets if we hadn’t thought them through. For example, placing the dishwasher on the wrong side of the sink would have left it visible from the front door; instead we tucked it behind the island, which is both hide-and-convenient for unloading.

kitchen-remodel-open-island-with-pendant-450

Renovations are full of details, and even with careful planning you’ll likely need a few adjustments along the way. The goal is to catch the big visual and functional issues early so fixes are simple, not structural. If nothing else, avoid having to tear down a wall to recenter an opening by three inches — trust us, that’s a lesson worth learning now.

If you want to read more about our kitchen process, see these project posts: Choosing a New Layout; Gutting & Rebuilding; The Big Reveal (with sources); A Video Tour of How We Organized Our Cabinets & Drawers; How We Added the Living Room Built-Ins.

kitchen-remodel-final-shelves-angle-door