Objectales

Popular

How We Picked the Perfect Pink Exterior Paint

featured 80255

Choosing a paint color for a beach house turned out to be tougher than we expected. We shared a bunch of photoshopped options on social media a few weeks ago, and the slideshow-style previews sparked a lot of feedback. We also talked through the decision process on our podcast (Episode #28 and Episode #31), and those conversations cover many of the practical considerations that affected our choice—things like protecting the original wood front door and how the house fits in with neighboring homes.

Photoshopped house color options

Below is a visual recap of the factors that guided our decision and why we finally landed on a single color. We examined each possibility one at a time, starting with the existing look.

The Existing Color

Existing green-gray siding with creamy trim

When we bought the house it had green-gray siding and creamy yellow trim. Our first instinct was to freshen it up by painting the trim white, which instantly made the house feel brighter and more beach-appropriate. For a moment we considered keeping the siding the same color to honor the original look, but it read a little muddy and subdued next to the brighter, more colorful homes around us. Since we were already planning to replace rotted siding and do a full repaint, choosing a new color felt like a great opportunity to give the house a livelier identity.

Blue

Photoshopped blue house option

We both love blue and have used many blue tones in previous projects—navy, teal, aqua and lighter blue-grays are all classic beach-house choices. The problem here was that three houses in our row were already some shade of blue, and painting ours blue would have simply made us blend in with that cluster. We liked the idea of standing out rather than becoming “yet another blue house on the street,” so we moved on to other color families.

Neighboring blue houses

Green

Photoshopped green house option

Greens—minty, seafoam, or more yellow-toned avocado shades—felt too close to the blues already present. Testers tended to read blue in the actual light and against neighboring houses, so green didn’t provide the contrast we wanted. If our goal was to contribute to a cheerful, rainbow-like streetscape, choosing a color farther from blue on the color wheel made more sense.

Gray / Beige

Photoshopped neutral house option

Neutrals appealed to us because they feel classic and allow colorful accents—porch furniture, planters, and small architectural details—to take center stage. Some of the light tan and gray houses in town looked very appropriate for a waterside setting, so a neutral was a serious contender. It also felt like a safe, low-risk choice that could balance the stronger colors nearby.

After reviewing inspiration photos and walking the neighborhood, we saw how lovely soft neutrals can be when paired with crisp white trim and colorful accessories. However, we still weren’t completely convinced that neutral was the best way to make the house feel lively and unique.

White

Photoshopped white house option

White is undeniably crisp and beachy and was a frequent image on our inspiration boards. We loved the idea, especially with a dark roof and colorful planters or porch furniture. But two practical drawbacks gave us pause: maintenance and loss of architectural detail. A friend with white fiber cement siding warned that it shows dirt quickly and requires frequent cleaning—something we wanted to avoid for a rental property. Also, the ornate porch columns would largely disappear in an all-white treatment, which felt like a missed opportunity to showcase the house’s character.

Yellow

Photoshopped yellow house option

Yellow was a popular suggestion online and felt sweet and summery—there’s something nostalgic about a buttery or sunny yellow house. Our contractor’s plan to re-side the entire house led us to check stock factory-finished HardiePlank colors as well as custom-painted primed boards. The factory colors were mostly neutrals and tended to be more muted than the bright, playful hues we liked for a beach town. After seeing several yellow houses in person, the stock options didn’t give us that “this is it” excitement.

We’re choosing HardiePlank fiber cement siding for durability and low maintenance. That allowed us to consider either stock factory colors or primed boards we could paint any shade we wanted. Ultimately, the available stock yellows weren’t quite right for the lively feel we envisioned.

Pink / Coral

Photoshopped pink coral house option

Pink and coral were among the most talked-about options in the comments, and for good reason: they’re bold, fun, and unmistakably beachy. A pink or coral exterior would be a big departure from the calmer blues and neutrals we usually favor. At first it felt like a big commitment, but pink also seemed like the perfect complementary color to sit between two blue houses and to coordinate with our wood front door.

Test color swatches including pink

Then, unexpectedly, inspiration arrived in the form of a paper coffee cup. A peachy-coral cup from a boutique hotel caught Sherry’s eye and sparked the realization that the perfect color might already exist in everyday life. The cup’s tone—best described as a warm coral with peach undertones—matched a Sherwin Williams shade called Mellow Coral and felt like the missing link between the blue neighbors and our house’s original features.

The coffee cup that inspired the color

We painted dozens of swatches and watched neighbors stop to take a look. The reaction was overwhelmingly positive—people liked how the peachy coral sat between the two blue houses and how it felt playful without being garish. It solved several problems at once: it provided contrast with the blues, worked with our wood door, and conveyed a bright, inviting beach-house vibe.

Photoshopped peachy coral house

So that’s how a little paper cup helped us make a major decision: we’re going with a peachy-coral exterior that complements the street and highlights the home’s personality. It feels right for renters and neighbors alike, and it gives the house a distinct, cheerful identity. One big decision down, many more to go—but at least the paint color debate is finally settled.