Objectales

Popular

Home Renovation Regrets: What We Wish We Had Done Differently

featured 84112

Looking back at the way we updated our earlier homes, there are plenty of design choices we’d change if we could. In this post we break down five things we’d redo, plus share the latest on our recent deck removal and other updates around the yard. Yes — the massive deck is gone, and the backyard already feels wonderfully open. But like a classic “If You Give a Mouse a Cookie” moment, checking one big item off the list has created a handful of new projects we need to tackle. We also take a moment to grade Sherwin-Williams’ Color of the Year and explain why John won’t pledge loyalty to a single tool brand.

You can listen to the full conversation on the Young House Love podcast via Apple Podcasts, Google Play, Stitcher, TuneIn Radio, or wherever you get podcasts. Use this page to view the photos and notes we mention in the episode. If you’re reading in a feed reader, you may need to open the full post to see the player.

What’s New

img 84112 1

  • We explain why we decided to remove the deck in Episode #51 of the podcast. The deck felt like a huge, awkward appendage attached to the back of the house and it blocked sightlines from the kitchen to the yard.
  • The photo above shows the view from the kitchen after demo: the railing used to hide most of the grass, and now Sherry can’t stop smiling at the openness.
  • We don’t have a perfect “before” photo from that exact angle, but another kitchen-window shot taken during demo illustrates how dominant the deck felt — almost like a cage dropped into the yard.

img 84112 2

  • Here’s how the house looked immediately after the deck came down. Removing the deck revealed more original architecture and opened visual access to the yard, but also highlighted a few problem areas that we’ll need to address.

img 84112 3

  • From the other side you can see the massive stump we inherited (ugh) along with the original brick steps that we’re glad are still intact.

img 84112 4

  • A throwback photo from 2012 shows the tree that used to sit where the stump now remains. The tree was very large and close to the house; the inspector and our arborist recommended removal for safety reasons, which left that stubborn stump under the old deck.

img 84112 5

  • Since taking the deck down we’ve already moved the air conditioning unit, had an electrician tidy all the loose wiring, and arranged to have the stump ground down. After those fixes, the space is starting to feel much cleaner and more original.

img 84112 6

  • There’s still a lot to do (including powerwashing the brick), but we’re encouraged by the increased visual space and potential for landscaping and outdoor living improvements.

img 84112 7

What’s Not

  • We discuss Sherwin-Williams’ Color of the Year and how it relates to paint choices we’ve made, such as the recent refinishing and painting of a clawfoot tub. We also mention other color forecasts from brands like Behr and Benjamin Moore in past episodes.
  • Color announcements are fun to consider, but they’re just one piece of how a room comes together — lighting, finishes, and layout matter just as much.

Design Regrets

img 84112 8

  • Episode #62 includes a mention of our most frequently cited regret: the awkward P-shaped opening between the kitchen and dining area in our second home. That layout created odd flow and sightline problems we would not repeat.
  • The photo above also highlights other missteps we made in that house, including awkward floor transitions and poorly placed tall cabinetry that would have been better grouped on one wall.
  • Another image shows how multiple flooring materials — hardwood, cork, parquet, wide-plank pine, and tile — fragment a home visually. If we could redo it, we’d simplify the materials and transitions for a more cohesive flow.

img 84112 9

  • A holiday photo featuring one of our favorite Christmas trees also exposes those flooring breaks: hardwood in the foreground, cork in the kitchen, and parquet in the hall and living room.

img 84112 10

  • On the back side of the house there was wide-plank pine in the master and tile in the sunroom — both disconnected from the parquet living room. If we redesigned it from scratch we’d strive for more continuity.

img 84112 11

  • We also wish we had made the fireplace double-sided so it could be enjoyed from both the kitchen and living room. We love how the kitchen-facing side turned out after its makeover — imagine that same treatment on the other side.

img 84112 12

  • Another regret: not installing a backsplash sooner in our first kitchen. The empty wall in the move-out photo clearly demonstrates how much better the space would have felt with tile. A simple subway tile backsplash is very do-able for a motivated first-time tiler.
  • We’ve written about refinishing hardwood floors, installing prefinished flooring, and different methods like nail-down and glue-down. If you’re planning floors, read before you start so you pick the best approach for your house.
  • For more before-and-after photos from our projects, check our house tour pages in our previous posts and archives.

We’re Digging

  • On the tools front, John’s been enjoying a Ryobi ONE+ Cordless Hybrid Trimmer/Edger that was about $90. He likes that the hybrid model can run on battery or plug in if needed — convenient for beach house and home use.
  • On TV, we recommend The Good Place. Start with Season 1 to understand the characters and setup before watching Season 2.

If you want a consolidated list of products, projects, and favorites we’ve mentioned across episodes, we maintain a master list of picks and discoveries from previous shows.

Finally, thanks to Universal Furniture for supporting the podcast episode. They sponsored the show and provided a giveaway associated with this episode. We appreciate their support of independent content like ours.

img 84112 15

Thanks for listening — and for following along with the messy, joyful work of making a house into a home.

*This post contains affiliate links*