4 Tips to Score Thrift Store Finds
I take pride in some odd little talents: cartwheeling into a pool, reciting every word to old commercial jingles and 90s rap songs, and the mysterious fact that my husband John and I, both right-handed, somehow made two left-handed children. I also get a kick out of watching our very tall kids grow up—especially since I’m only 5’2″.
One thing I don’t often think of as a skill is my knack for finding secondhand furniture. It’s not magic or luck so much as frequency and persistence: I look often. I check thrift stores, Craigslist, and Facebook Marketplace regularly. Most of the time nothing grabs me, but every so often something fantastic turns up. For example, I found a Restoration Hardware inlay dresser that retails for $1,800 on Craigslist for $400. That find wasn’t accidental; it took time and a few deliberate moves.

Instead of flaunting my ridiculous memory for rap lyrics, here are the practical, repeatable tips I use for secondhand shopping success. These are tactics you can apply to score great pieces for your home—without relying on dumb luck.
Lesson #1: Show Interest and Be Persistent
That inlay dresser story boils down to one thing: determination. I saw the listing months before I purchased it. I loved it, but the price was $600—above my budget for a beach house dresser. I didn’t ignore it; I reached out and let the seller know I was very interested but my top offer was $400, and that I could come with cash right away if she accepted.
She replied that she wasn’t planning to lower the price yet, but she appreciated the note. I continued to watch the listing. When it disappeared from the site a few weeks later I noticed right away. Because we already had a message thread, I sent one more friendly note saying, in effect, “If it’s still available, I’ll take it for $400 cash.” She agreed. That’s how the dresser ended up at our beach house.
The takeaway: don’t be afraid to declare your interest, even if you’re not ready to pay full price. Start a conversation with the seller so you have contact information, and follow up. Patience and gentle persistence often beat a single impulse purchase.
Lesson #2: Be Vigilant and Ready to Pounce
I also scored a marble-topped dresser on Facebook Marketplace for what felt like a steal—around $100. The marble slab on top alone would have been expensive to source new. I saw the listing within an hour of it being posted because I check Marketplace frequently—usually a few minutes while relaxing in the evening. Because I act fast, I was first in line. I had cash ready and was at the seller’s house within an hour, so no one else could swoop in.

If you want to find good secondhand items, you have to increase the frequency of your searches. Even five minutes a night, a few nights a week, raises your chances tremendously. When you find something you want, move fast: get cash, arrange pickup quickly, and be ready to commit. Sellers often honor “first come, first served,” and hesitation can cost you the sale.
Lesson #3: Recruit Spies
My favorite bedroom rug came from a local consignment shop after a friend texted me photos of pieces she’d seen. Let your friends and local design-savvy acquaintances know what you’re hunting for—whether it’s a colorful wool rug, a midcentury chair, or a marble dresser. If they see something that fits your taste, they can send a picture or the shop name, and you’ll have a head start.

When my friend sent the rug photo I didn’t hesitate: I called the shop, confirmed the price, got cash, and drove straight there with my husband. We always take a moment to check secondhand items in person—yes, including a quick sniff for odors—and the rug was in our car within 20 minutes. Building a network of friends who’ll tip you off is a small, powerful strategy.
Lesson #4: Be Curious and Ask
Another great find came from Facebook Marketplace. The listing was for a large piece of driftwood, but I noticed two chairs in the background and messaged the seller to ask if the chairs were for sale. They were. The seller not only sold the chairs to me, she offered to drive them to our house because they were too big for our SUV.

Anything visible in a listing photo is worth asking about. The worst outcome is a polite no; the best is that you buy a hidden gem. For large items, offer a small delivery fee (for example, $20) if the seller can drop it off—this often saves you time, rental fees, and hassle.

After we posted photos of those chairs, someone recognized them as potential Russell Woodard pieces—midcentury designers whose original chairs can sell for thousands. We paid $140 for the pair, delivery included. Getting a designer score like that is rare, but possible when you look often, ask questions, and act quickly.

At the end of the day, secondhand shopping is about filling your home with pieces you love, often at a fraction of the cost of new. My practical advice: check local listings frequently, make your interest known, be prepared with cash, ask about anything in photos, and lean on friends to scout finds. If you do these things consistently, you’ll increase your odds of finding amazing furniture and decor.
P.S. We’ve put together a long list of practical tips for buying used furniture and navigating Craigslist in the past—those older tips still hold up, so it’s worth reviewing if you want even more ideas for scoring great secondhand items. Happy thrifting!
P.P.S. If anything in the photos above caught your eye and you’re wondering where it’s from, we keep source lists for both our beach house and our Richmond home with details about many of the pieces shown.








