How to Choose Shutters for a Historic Beach House
You may have seen some of our duplex exterior progress on social media, so here’s a more detailed update with answers to the many questions you sent. We’ll cover shutters, steps, metal awnings, the diamond-door situation, and other exterior decisions that have shaped this 100+ year-old house’s renovation.

As a reminder, historic review requirements in town mean we must keep many of the home’s original features: the front doors, the roofline, window locations, and the corbels along the eaves. That said, the review board allowed us to adjust corbel spacing so they wrap the whole house, which saved us from recreating dozens of rotted originals.

When we started, the exterior needed a lot of attention: rotted siding, failing roofing, a collapsing porch, and windows that had been altered or covered up (including diamond panes that had been hidden with drywall). We replaced most of the deteriorated materials with more durable products—HardiePlank cement board siding and composite corbels among them—so the house will stand up better to coastal weather over time.

The Historic Review Board’s goal is to preserve the neighborhood’s original look while allowing modern, long-lasting materials. With that framework, most exterior changes have to match the original shape and style so the historic downtown still feels cohesive.

Since the big demo earlier in the year, the exterior is nearly finished: roofing, siding, windows, and shutters are complete. The porch floor and columns are next. The transformation has been dramatic and we’re really happy with how the house is shaping up.

Hunting Down Operable-Looking Shutters
The shutters unexpectedly became one of the biggest decisions. New historic rules require shutters to appear operable—meaning they must look like they could close—so cheap vinyl fixed shutters weren’t acceptable. Real operable shutters are authentic to the period, even if most homeowners never actually close them for storms.

Custom, truly operable shutters quoted by local vendors were astonishingly expensive—around $1,000 per pair—so we hunted for a more affordable solution. We found pre-primed composite shutters in sizes that nearly matched our windows and bought enough to cover the front. They were a fraction of the cost of custom wood shutters, and because they’re composite they won’t rot.

One size we chose was slightly narrower than the window opening, so they won’t literally close over the glass. That’s fine here because the mandate is visual: shutters need to look operable rather than actually function as storm protection. If you need shutters that fully close, a custom option may be necessary.

Hardware selection can be confusing, so we kept it simple and picked traditional Pintle-style hinges and decorative shutter dogs to hold the panels open. Total hardware for ten shutters was reasonable and, combined with the shutters themselves and painting, the final cost was far below the custom quotes.

Because the house already had vinyl replacement windows, we couldn’t mount the hinges into original wood frames. Instead the shutters are mounted just outside the window frame, which preserves the warranty on the windows and still looks authentic from the street.

Choosing a Shutter Paint Color
Sherry wanted mint shutters on a white house from the start, so we tested a handful of mint-like colors using removable paint decals to see how they read in different light. We tested five Sherwin-Williams shades and ultimately landed on a soft mint called Pale Patina. It felt like the right historic-but-cheerful tone and even seemed to echo a faded mint we discovered under some old stair risers on site.

The shutters arrived pre-primed, so we applied two coats of exterior paint and finished them just before installation. The color complements the house and ties nicely to other nearby architectural colors that inspired us.

What About the Front Doors?
There’s been a lot of chatter about the diamond-paned doors you may have seen on social. Because the house is historic, the original front doors must remain in place. The diamond-paned doors we tracked down are intended for the back of the house, which will create a nice visual echo of the diamond windows up front and give balance to both sides of the property.

We tested painting the front doors mint to match the shutters, but after stripping them we fell for the natural wood look. They’re a little rough and need patching—especially around older knob holes—so keeping them raw means extra work to make them secure and clean. If it all comes together, we’ll sand, patch, and seal them to preserve that warm wood tone that pairs nicely with the brick steps.

Metal Awnings, Backyard Changes, and the Steps
Out back we widened the second floor slightly and added more windows and two metal awnings in a dark bronze tone to match the tin roof out front. We originally got custom awning quotes that were very expensive, but we found affordable pre-made options that gave us the same look at a fraction of the cost. We positioned the awnings high enough to preserve views and maximize light inside.

The backyard will also gain porch lanterns, stairs, outdoor showers, and a privacy fence that can open to combine both sides if one family rents the whole duplex. We think the backyard could become one of the best spots in the property once landscaping and lighting are finished.

For the front entry we chose wide brick steps with a mitered corner detail to echo the brickwork on our other home. The mason also redid the concrete pad beneath the steps and installed a brick border around the foundation to reduce splash-back and protect the skim-coated surface. Porch and stair railings will be added later in a historically appropriate white picket style.

We still have interior work underway—drywall is complete and next up is primer, paint, trim, and doors—plus porch rebuilding. There’s a lot happening, and we’ll share more updates as these final exterior elements and landscaping come together. Also, we can’t wait for the day the Port-O-Potty finally leaves so we can celebrate on those new brick steps.
P.S. If you want to follow the duplex rebuild from the beginning, we’ve documented the project with a series of posts and a podcast episode that go into detail about the process and costs.
*This post contains affiliate links*








