Objectales

Popular

The Tile We’d Install Again and the One We’d Skip

featured 88812

Tiling was one of the most intimidating items on our duplex to-do list this year — four bathrooms, two mudrooms, and two remaining backsplashes — so it’s a huge relief to say that nearly all of those floors, showers, and tub surrounds are finished (about 95% complete). Today we’ll walk through how they turned out, share lessons we learned, and highlight the tiles we’d buy again as well as the ones we’d think twice about attempting.

img 88812 1

floor tile | wall tile | shower floor | grout: frost | door: SW Oyster Bay

After two long weekends of tiling, we completed all six floors ourselves — two mudrooms and four bathrooms — but hired our contractor’s crew to install the remaining shower surrounds so we could stay on schedule. Their crew finished the four surrounds in less than a week. For the shower walls we chose classic white subway tile: simple, affordable, and unobtrusive so it wouldn’t compete with the patterned floor tiles we selected. Because of that, this post focuses mainly on the floor tiles and what we learned from installing them.

img 88812 2

floor tile | wall tile | shower floor | grout: warm gray | door: SW White Truffle

For the subway tile we used an affordable 3 x 6″ porcelain subway tile installed in a standard running bond pattern. Two en-suite showers got white herringbone tile on the floor, which added subtle interest without feeling busy. We shared our original tile selections when deciding on tile, cabinets, and paint, and made one last-minute swap after seeing tiles in the rooms next to the painted doors — a reminder that mockups can look different in the actual space.

img 88812 3

We intentionally limited ourselves to larger tiles with bold patterns rather than small mosaics because larger tiles move installation along faster. Still, even among larger tiles some patterns were much quicker and more foolproof to install than others. We love how every floor looks now, but a few tiles were considerably more time-consuming. If speed and ease are important — or if you’re a newbie tiler — these notes should help you choose tiles that are simpler and more predictable to install.

The Square Patterned Tiles

img 88812 4

floor tile | grout: warm gray | door: SW White Truffle

The blue square patterned tiles were the fastest and most straightforward to install. Two factors made them easy: they’re square, and the pattern is symmetrical on all sides. That meant tiles could be placed in any orientation, cuts were easier to reuse, and we were always working with right angles. The tile sizes — roughly 8 x 8″ and 9 x 9″ for the two rooms — were manageable and covered the floors quickly without being heavy or fiddly. Each of these rooms took us around two hours to lay.

img 88812 5

floor tile | grout: warm gray | door: SW White Truffle | wall: SW Spare White

Although they’re simple square tiles, the finished floors have a lot of visual interest — exactly what we wanted. Both are porcelain, so they’re low maintenance and don’t need sealing like cement or natural stone tiles. One change we’d make next time is choosing a darker gray grout in one room to make the diamond pattern read more strongly; we stuck with a single grout color for cost-efficiency but a darker tone would’ve helped the pattern recede and pop as intended.

The Marble Hex Tile

img 88812 8

floor tile | grout: frost | door: SW Oyster Bay

This hex tile is porcelain with a marble-like finish and may be our favorite. The classic marble look feels bright and the geometric overlay gives it a unique character. At roughly 8 x 8″, the tile was manageable and covered the room quickly, though laying hexes took a bit longer than square tiles because of the shape and the tile’s asymmetrical surface pattern.

With this tile you can create two distinct looks by rotating pieces; we laid out both options and chose the orientation we preferred. Hex tiles require careful layout to avoid spacing drift — one tile placed slightly off early on can magnify in later rows. To reduce surprises we dry-laid many tiles before mixing thinset. That upfront work made setting them much faster.

img 88812 11

Final verdict: this hex tile is a little trickier than square tiles but still very manageable. Using 1/16″ spacers kept things consistently aligned and the grout color helped disguise minor inconsistencies.

Sidenote: we used a premixed, non-sealing grout (Mapei) that’s flexible, stain-resistant, and durable — after a year of heavy use it still looks great with minimal maintenance.

The Patterned Hex Tile

The other hex we installed in the hall bathroom looked beautiful but was the most frustrating to lay. It shared the usual hex challenges — non-square shape and an asymmetrical pattern — but the pattern was particularly picky. That meant several awkward cuts and limited ability to reuse scraps. We even missed that one tile had been rotated incorrectly until a week later at grouting time, requiring removal and replacement and an extra day of waiting for thinset cure.

img 88812 14

We also ran short on material mid-install, which added to the delay. Based on our experience and reports from others, order about 25% extra for this patterned hex (rather than the typical 10–15%).

Final verdict: beautiful but not beginner-friendly. If speed and ease are priorities, skip this complex patterned hex; if you love the result and are prepared for the extra time and careful planning, it’s worth it.

The Chevron Mudroom Tile

Downstairs the mudrooms use a large chevron tile (17″ x 35″). Because each tile is long and rectangular, the rooms filled quickly and installation moved fast — the rooms are nearly the combined size of the bathrooms, so larger tiles were a real time-saver. The tradeoffs: these tiles are heavy and a bit awkward to cut. I had to get creative on the wet saw to fit them under the blade, and keeping large tiles level requires attention — we used LASH spacers to help with uniform spacing and leveling.

img 88812 17

One minor frustration: the manufacturer recommends a 2/17″ spacer to align the tile’s zigzag. That’s an odd size and not widely available, so we used a 1/16″ spacer, which is close enough for a good result. For a large room we’d choose this tile again — it’s durable, attractive, and gets a lot of compliments in person.

Final verdict: large tiles speed up installation and look great, but they’re heavier to handle and require careful leveling and the right spacers.

The Herringbone Mudroom Tile

Last — and by far the hardest — was a tri-color herringbone floor composed of long porcelain tiles in pink, white, and taupe. The combination of three alternating colors, the herringbone layout, and the many angled cuts created a perfect storm of difficulty:

  • Three-color sequence required constant attention to avoid mistakes
  • Herringbone demanded numerous angled cuts that are less forgiving than straight cuts
  • Scrap pieces were difficult to reuse because of alternating colors and angles
  • Meticulous spacing was essential to keep the pattern from drifting

Because of these factors and the room’s size, this was the only space that took us an entire day. It took significant mental energy to lay out the pattern, make precise angled cuts, and maintain the color sequence. We’re thrilled with the final look, but it’s not a project to underestimate.

Final verdict: most complex and time-consuming choice. It looks amazing, but expect a long day and lots of careful measuring if you attempt this pattern — or consider a smaller or simpler room for a similar effect.

One More Thing — Cutting Around Toilet Flanges

Many people asked how we cut the round openings around toilet flanges. While an angle grinder makes a clean circle, we didn’t have one, so we used our wet saw and a simple multi-step method. First mark the area, then make two long cuts at shallow angles to remove large chunks. Next, make many short close cuts along the edge — like teeth — and break off the pieces. The teeth usually fracture away, and any remaining bits can be trimmed with the blade. The result isn’t a perfect circle, but the toilet will cover it and a flat, solid surface for the toilet base is what matters most.

img 88812 21

img 88812 22

The upstairs toilets and vanities were installed last week, so we hope to visit soon and finish the remaining touches. Overall, tiling the duplex was a big investment of time and energy, but the variety of patterns gives each room its own personality and the porcelain selections will last for years with minimal upkeep.

More Tiling Projects & How-To Resources

If you want more step-by-step guidance or inspiration from our past projects, check out these topics we’ve documented:

  • How to install a subway tile backsplash (with video)
  • How to mix thinset and how to install penny tile
  • How to install subway tile in a herringbone pattern
  • How to install cement board and large floor tiles
  • How to install a herringbone marble backsplash using mastic
  • How to install oversized tile in an outdoor area
  • How we customized a hex mosaic in the beach house

*This post contains affiliate links*