Before-and-After: Two Airbnb Kitchen Makeovers
Big day—finally! We’re excited to share a full tour of both completed duplex kitchens, and announce that our Airbnb listings are officially live. Read on for lots of photos and details about how to book a week in Cape Charles if you want to come see it for yourself. We think it’s an ideal summer spot, but we might be a little biased.

The first photo above shows the kitchen with the blue tile and wood cabinets (on the right side of the duplex). You may remember bits of this from earlier posts about installing Ikea cabinets and tiling the backsplashes. For this post, I’ll start on the other side—the kitchen with the pink tile and blue cabinets—then show how both came together.

To appreciate the transformation, here’s a quick rewind to when we first bought the duplex in 2017. The room that’s now the larger kitchen was previously separated by a narrow doorway and orange-trimmed openings. The old layout squeezed a kitchen into a former side porch, which never felt right.

One of the biggest improvements was widening the doorway and adding a transom to connect spaces and maximize light and flow. Now you can see the tiled focal wall from the front door—much more welcoming and practical.

The room that became the main kitchen was previously a dining room with an odd fridge placement—clearly a better fit for a full kitchen. We raised the base of the window so cabinetry could run beneath it and added pocket doors to conceal the laundry when needed.

Both kitchens are now fully stocked for guests: blenders, toasters, coffee makers, pots and pans, knives, silverware, serving bowls, plates, cups, wine glasses, mugs, microwaves, Tupperware, and basic pantry staples. Each side even has a cheese grater, wine opener, and chip clips—small touches that make a rental feel like home.

We decided not to keep the patterned tile on the stove wall so the space didn’t feel visually overwhelming. Instead we installed horizontal planking—sometimes called faux shiplap—on that wall. The planking is made from thin plywood cut into planks, installed with small spacers, and painted in semi-gloss for easy cleaning. We color-matched it to the cabinets so everything blends, and it provides a wipeable, durable surface that feels beachy and modern.

Appliance choices were practical and low-maintenance. We used stainless steel for the slide-in range and refrigerator, and placed a white countertop microwave to blend with the planked wall. Because the duplex requires a central firewall, we couldn’t vent the hood outside, so we used a built-in range hood insert with charcoal filters for recirculation. That’s why there’s a small gap above the hood—to allow clean air to escape after filtration.

For the refrigerator we chose a simple top-freezer model and avoided ice-makers and water dispensers to minimize maintenance and potential leaks in a seasonal rental. We leave ice and a filtered pitcher available for guests.

One detail we hadn’t used before is a cabinet-fronted dishwasher. We tucked it into the focal cabinet run so the back wall remains uninterrupted. Our plumber handled the installation and we attached the custom panel and hardware ourselves; it required precise measuring but was straightforward with the template provided.

We also installed custom floating shelves, built to be 8″ deep so they’re ideal for mugs, small bowls, and decor rather than heavy dinnerware. The pine we used matches the blonde tone of the cabinets, so the shelves look cohesive with the kitchen. Sherry sealed them with a clear finish to echo the floors and add warmth.

Cabinet organization will follow systems we use at our beach house: plates and flatware near the sink, pots and pans in the drawers beside the stove, lesser-used items in upper cabinets, and pantry items in the adjacent mudroom/laundry room. There’s enough storage for basics and a few extra cabinets and drawers to spare—plus essentials like storage bags, cooking oil, and serving tools are all supplied.

Next week we expect to publish photos of both mudroom/laundry rooms and show the finished sleeping nooks. After that the only major area left is the backyard, which is still in progress.

If you’re interested in renting, each side of the duplex is listed separately and sleeps up to six guests (plus one baby; pack ’n play and sheet provided). If you want both sides, check availability for the same dates and you can book the whole house. Currently we’re offering weekly rentals for the peak summer season (Saturday to Saturday, late June through August). We’re not accepting pets at this time to be mindful of allergies and shared-wall noise concerns. Off-season shorter stays are planned for the future, and we’ll announce those when they’re available.

Opening the duplex for reservations is both thrilling and a little nerve-wracking, so please be patient as we work through any early kinks. We’ll share what we learn along the way. If you want a preview of things to do in town, check our Cape Charles travel guide for local recommendations and highlights.
P.S. Want to see more? We’ve already revealed the other finished rooms, bathroom tiling, layout planning, and renovation stories in our duplex archive for anyone who wants a deeper dive.
*This post contains affiliate links*








