Duplex Front Porch Makeover: Before and After Reveal
It’s been a while since we’ve shown the front of the duplex (blame winter), but today’s the day — and the transformation is dramatic. Things have genuinely turned a corner.

There’s still no finished landscaping, the grass is patchy, and Sean the contractor’s large sign hasn’t been removed yet. Even so, compared to where we started, the curb appeal is night and day.

We removed all the non-original elements that cluttered the facade — the plastic wagon wheels and abacus trim from the 1970s, undersized plastic shutters, a broken vinyl railing, satellite dishes, and even duct tape along the roofline. At the same time we restored or reintroduced original details where possible: a metal porch roof, larger operable shutters, square porch columns, corbels along the roof, wide brick steps, and those charming diamond windows that make me giddy.

We’ve already written about our big exterior decisions — siding, roofing, and the shutter color — so today I want to focus on the front porch updates and the design choices that brought everything together.

First, let’s address the tiny doormats. They are laughably small — postage-stamp size — and we’ll be replacing them with much larger mats. Put that aside and take in the other improvements: matching mailboxes, readable house numbers, oversized lanterns to light the entry, and composite decking so we won’t be dealing with rot. We also added potted plants and teak benches that immediately elevate the porch.

We don’t have polished before photos of the door area alone, but earlier images show the old mismatched storm doors that we removed as soon as we could. The previous porch condition was worse than those photos imply.

Structurally, the front porch was so rotten that the support beams and framing needed a complete rebuild. We carefully preserved the original transom windows above the doors while reconstructing the porch from the ground up.

The progress over the last year and a half feels substantial — it honestly looks like a different house now.

Once we removed the storm doors, we decided to keep the original front doors. Because the house is in a historic district, any door changes require approval from the town’s historic review board, so we were relieved to like and keep the originals. Initially we considered painting them the same mint color as the shutters, but with so many windows and shutters already showing that color, we wanted a different tone for contrast.

Our first thought was to restore a natural wood look. We had the doors professionally stripped and sanded in a shop to remove as much old paint as possible while taking precautions for lead paint and preserving the thin, delicate original doors. The cost for that professional stripping was about $400.

Even after that work, though, stubborn paint remained in recesses and cracks. Up close you could still see glue bubbles and a large crack that made a flawless wood restoration impractical. A thick gel stain could have masked some of those imperfections, as we did at our pink house, but once we installed the porch lights, mailboxes, house numbers, and hardware, a different idea began to feel right.

We kept thinking about a rich charcoal paint that would echo the metal porch roof and balance the cheerful green shutters. It would ground the facade, create contrast, and help conceal the remaining imperfections in the original wood. Many neighboring houses with original doors are painted, too, so it felt like a sensible and sympathetic choice.

We chose Sherwin-Williams Urbane Bronze, a layered, versatile shade that sits between a true black and a warm brown-tinged tone — a great match for the tin roof and the other dark porch accents. In the end, painting the doors was the right call: it concealed flaws, coordinated with the operable shutters and oversized lanterns, and let the mailbox and house numbers pop.

Installing the address numbers was straightforward. We used standard off-the-shelf house numbers that mount flush to the siding; the package includes a template, which we adjusted to space and level the numbers exactly how we wanted. Local code requires numbers be at least 4 inches tall and visible from the street, so that was another practical reason to choose bold, readable numbers.

To bring some warmth back after painting the doors, we introduced wood tones elsewhere: basket-style ceramic planters that read like woven baskets, and sizable teak benches at each end of the porch. Once we add a larger doormat — maybe a single runner that spans both doors — the warmer accents will feel even more intentional.

We also installed faux outdoor trees for low-maintenance greenery. These are the same style we use at our beach house and home — they give instant height and presence without ongoing care. I haven’t styled them fully for photos yet, so they’ll look even better once we add mats, finish landscaping, and fluff the foliage.

If you follow our newsletter, you may have seen a peek inside when the doors were open. We painted the stair risers to match each unit’s interior door color — White Truffle on the left and Oyster Bay on the right — so opening the dark, moody exterior doors reveals a cheerful, beachy color inside each entry.

This before photo highlights how our choices were driven by light and how colors read differently depending on orientation. We adjusted which colors went on which side so each stair riser reads best in its particular light.

That wraps up the porch update. We’re hoping for an early spring so we can finish landscaping, add a path, seed the lawn, and complete the remaining exterior touches. The plan is to have the duplex ready for photos and rentals this spring and summer — Airbnb listings should go live around April, with rentals starting in early summer.

We still need to finish the interior and wrap up the backyard, but the porch feels like a major milestone. It’s amazing how much a thoughtful entry — the right doors, lighting, hardware, and a few well-chosen accents — can change a home’s personality.
P.S. To see the duplex progress from the past 1.5 years, there’s a whole category dedicated to duplex progress.
*This post contains affiliate links*








