Objectales

Popular

House Hunting: What Buyers Look For and Overlook

featured 49051

Q: I have a house-hunting question. What do you look for? What do you look past? Help! My main complaint about all the older homes in our price range is that they feel dated, but that seems to be what you guys look for. How do you know which dated houses are worth buying and which ones are lost causes? I keep worrying we’ll end up in a money pit! – Aviva (not the one from Housewives of NY).

A: First, glad to hear you’re not NYC Aviva — that made me laugh. We get this question a lot, so here’s a clear way to think about it when you’re house hunting. The short version: ignore cosmetic issues you can change affordably; focus on the structural and layout elements you can’t change without major expense. Below are the common cosmetic things to look past and the critical features to pay attention to.

  • Bad paint on walls or trim — paint is inexpensive and transformative.
  • Outdated wallpaper or borders — removeable without breaking the bank.
  • Furniture that’s not your style — staging can be temporary.
  • Ugly curtains or window treatments — easy to replace.
  • Dark brick or wood paneling — paint can brighten and modernize.
  • Unfamiliar light fixtures — swap them out for updated options.
  • Colored toilets or vintage fixtures — often replaceable at modest cost.

To illustrate, these are a few before photos from our first house to show how off-putting dated features can look — but also how fixable they are with a bit of work and planning:

Dated Dining Room With Blue Trim And Wallpaper
Dated Bedroom With Wallpaper Border And Cream Trim
Dated Den With Dark Wood Beams Brick And Wood Paneling
Dated Bathroom With Green Toilet

Those cosmetic problems can all be addressed, especially if you’re willing to do some DIY. Now, here are the things we always prioritize because they are expensive or difficult to change:

  • The neighborhood — you can’t move a house, and location affects resale and daily life.
  • The overall floor plan — relocating rooms or changing the layout is costly.
  • Room sizes and number of bathrooms — small bedrooms or too few baths are hard to fix.
  • Ceiling height and window placement — these affect light and feel and are not easy to alter.
  • Architectural features worth keeping, like a functional fireplace or attractive ceiling beams.
  • The lot and terrain — a steep drop-off or difficult grading can add major landscaping or structural costs.

Here are photos showing some of the “diamonds in the rough” we noticed. The same room with dated brick and paneling had a centered fireplace and architectural beams — features worth preserving and highlighting:

Dated Den With Dark Wood Beams Brick And Wood Paneling

Once we painted the dark surfaces and updated furnishings, the room felt completely different and much more modern:

After Photo Of Den With Painted Brick Walls And Paneling With White Beam And Udpated Furniture

Lot size was another major selling point for us. Our property was nearly an acre with a flat, wooded backyard — something you can’t change after purchase. Even if the landscaping was rough, the privacy, space, and potential for an easy-to-maintain yard made it worth the work.

Before Backyard With Boxwood Path And Wood Arch And Small Shed
After Backyard With Grassy Field And Small Shed

Practical tips for seeing past cosmetics: collect inspiration images you love from magazines or online and compare them to rooms in potential homes. If a room has the same size and shape as an image you admire, repainting, new curtains, lighting, and decor can replicate the look. Making a visual plan helps you imagine the possibilities and distinguish between superficial flaws and fundamental deal-breakers.

To avoid buying a money pit, always get a thorough home inspection. Inspectors can’t guarantee they’ll find every issue, but a qualified, experienced inspector who spends multiple hours checking the roof, crawlspace, vents, and systems will reveal many potential problems. That information gives you leverage to negotiate, request repairs, or walk away if major structural or expensive issues emerge. For us, a detailed inspection has been a critical step in both of our home purchases.

Finally, make lists: must-haves, nice-to-haves, and deal-breakers. That keeps you focused and prevents small, desirable features from clouding your judgment about essential elements like layout, location, and structural soundness. Ignore the paint and the curtains if the bones are solid — and if they aren’t, don’t be afraid to keep looking.