How to Coordinate Colors, Rugs, and Furniture in Your Home
The Homearama showhouse project is racing toward its deadline — the show opens May 1 — and with a baby due a few weeks before that, we’re hustling to get everything finished. We’ve shared bits of this journey before (see our other posts about the new house, the showhouse plans, putting the house in the showhouse, and choosing an exterior paint color), but there’s so much happening at once that this update will cover several different threads as we chase the calendar.
First, thank you for the massive response to the front door color poll. Nearly 38,000 votes rolled in, and rust held a steady lead with about 36%, followed by red at roughly 21%. We’re pausing before a final choice because the porch columns still need to be sealed, and the stain will deepen once sealed, which could affect which door color works best.

One surprising trend in the comments was a strong write-in for white. Sherry had wanted to include white as an option, but I talked her out of it, worrying it would show dirt too easily. The readers’ persistent “what about white?” prompted us to ask folks who actually have white doors how they liked them. The consensus: with a porch or overhang like ours, a white door can work beautifully and often looks wider and more elegant alongside white sidelights.
If the sealed beams, porch floor tile, and other layered elements end up feeling heavy, white could be the calming choice that unifies the entryway. We’ll wait to see how the columns look after sealing and will test paint swatches on the door before making the final call. We’ll report back once those tests are completed.

One exciting milestone: the porch columns are installed. It was a small but thrilling moment pulling up to see them in place. They still need sealing, which will deepen the wood tone, and we can’t wait to see how they finish out the porch’s overall look.

Inside the house, nearly every choice has become a balance between safe, broadly appealing options and bolder, more distinctive decisions. Since the house will eventually go on the market, we don’t want to create anything too polarizing. At the same time, Homearama encourages designers to be creative so each of the seven houses in the show offers something unique. This tension—“will this scare potential buyers?” versus “will this make the house memorable?”—has guided most of our selections, down to debating wall-to-wall carpet for the kids’ rooms.

With encouragement from the show organizers and the builder’s reminder that the house needs only one buyer, we’ve leaned toward a few bold moves while keeping an overall sellable aesthetic. That strategy gives us room for some showstopping elements in each room, while the team of builder, contractors, architect, real estate pros, and show coordinators help keep us grounded.
We’ve been checking items off the to-do list: all interior paint colors are chosen, and furniture choices are falling into place. Outfitting an entire house at once is a major undertaking—furniture, rugs, curtains, art, and accessories add up quickly—but with the drywall up, it’s much easier to visualize how each space will come together.

Decor budgets are tight: hardwired elements like lighting, plumbing, tile, and paint come from the builder’s budget, and each designer receives a modest amount for decor—often under $500 per room—so a single rug or sofa can exhaust a room’s allocation. To bridge that gap, Homearama arranged for the seven showhouses to borrow furniture from Green Front Furniture, which allowed us to secure key pieces without draining our budget. We spent a day there road-tripping through their massive selection and picked up as much as we could manage in one trip.

Even with that support, there’s still more to source, and each designer is filling out their homes by borrowing items, calling in favors, and working with local artists and shops. For us, that means reaching out to favorite makers and stores we’ve gotten to know through blogging, similar to how we coordinated donations for a previous pediatric hospital project.
Every dollar we save on furnishings and decor helps us give more to Richmond’s Habitat for Humanity. We’re donating our design fee to Habitat as well, and Homearama is collecting contributions from sponsors and ticket sales. When the show ends, some furnishings and decor will be donated to the local ReStore, so local shoppers should keep an eye out for deals.

Not everything is brand-new. We’ve been hunting secondhand shops for vintage finds to refresh with paint and new upholstery. One great thrift find was a wooden full-sized headboard for $9.98 that we plan to paint for the girls’ bedroom; it gives us a high-end look on a thrift-store budget. That headboard will sit against an accent wall planned for a cheerful stencil donated by Royal Design Studio, and you can already see the beginning of a built-in desk the carpenter is crafting from our quick wall sketches.

Because there’s no single client for this house, we’ve designed rooms for imagined future occupants—spaces that could work for a tween Clara who needs one desk for homework and another for art, and for an 8-year-old Barnacle who’ll have a built-in bed and storage system. Built-ins are a win for the builder to showcase custom work and an easy way for us to create functional, attractive spaces without having to construct them ourselves.

Here’s a peek into the living room: the space opens to the kitchen (this view faces away from the island). The island will be painted navy with gold pendants above it, and we’ll repeat that navy on the fireplace column across the room to make the white mantle and light stone surround pop. We’ve even commissioned an artist friend to paint a colorful portrait of Burger to hang above the mantel—a playful personal touch we couldn’t resist.

We’ll share more detailed room-by-room updates and mood boards as these spaces come together. Right now we have around 20 mood boards about 40% complete and plenty of finishing work to do. With our baby due in less than eight weeks, the pace is picking up — but we can’t wait to finish the house and show you the final result.
Psst — Want to see the finished showhouse? Check our full showhouse tour for final photos, floor plans, budget details, a video walk-through, and the showhouse furniture and accessories.








