Objectales

Popular

How to Repair Cracked or Broken Inlay on Furniture

featured 85072

Meet the dresser of my beach house dreams. Maybe you’ve already seen it on Instagram, but here’s the full story: a little like The Notebook, except it’s a dresser and me instead of two people.

blue gray inlay restoration hardware dresser in beach house nook

I found this piece on Craigslist. Yes—Craigslist. I was ecstatic. The dresser had originally been bought at HomeGoods for $1,200 (the seller even included a photo of the price sticker), was listed on Craigslist for $650, and the exact same model currently sells for $1,829 at Restoration Hardware. I loved it immediately, but $650 wasn’t in my beach house budget at the time.

beachy blue bedroom in historic home

I sent the seller a polite note saying the dresser was beautiful but out of my price range and asked her to let me know if she lowered it. She replied that she wasn’t willing to budge—so I tried to move on. But I couldn’t stop picturing that dresser in the bedroom nook at the beach house, so I refused to buy anything else for that spot. Call it patience or stubbornness.

About a month later she emailed me back: no takers at $650, would I take it for $400? That was the most I’d ever paid for a secondhand piece, but compared to the $1,829 retail price and the quality of a solid inlay dresser, $400 was an easy yes. The seller warned that a few inlay pieces needed repair, which I was comfortable handling myself.

blue gray inlay detail next to exposed brick

When we brought it home, the damage was visible up close. Some tiles were cracked or missing at a corner. If you’ve ever seen inlay pieces discounted “as-is” at stores, this is usually why: a tile has popped out, cracked, or shattered. But these pieces are often repairable, and that’s what made this find so worthwhile.

repair inlay on broken and cracked dresser with spackle

I researched how inlay furniture is put together and learned many pieces are set into a plaster-like filler. That led me to try joint compound (spackle) to fill the gaps—spackle sands smooth and can be painted to match surrounding tiles. After filling the cracks and letting the compound dry, I sanded the repair smooth and painted it to blend.

spackle fill to repair inlay tile that is missing or broken

Color matching is part art, part patience. I mixed paint from what we already had, keeping in mind that paint dries darker—so I aimed for a shade slightly lighter than the inlay. The blue-gray tones were easy to reproduce by combining the colors we had on hand. The yellow tile on the front right corner was harder to match, which is why that area still looks a little lighter in the photo below.

mixing paint to cover repaired inlay tiles

repaired inlay tile on dresser

The repair isn’t perfect yet, but it reads much better from a normal viewing distance. I plan to bring a yellower paint next trip to Cape Charles to fine-tune the match and add another thin coat of spackle where it shrank slightly while drying. Once I sand and touch up the paint, the repairs will blend even more seamlessly into the busy pattern of the inlay.

before photo of cracked and broken inlay tile

Even now, you really have to look for the repaired areas—the pattern disguises the patches well. That forgiving, intricate pattern is one of the reasons an inlay piece like this is worth rescuing: it’s durable, unique, and much more interesting than a mass-produced dresser priced similarly.

blue gray inlay dresser in beachy bedroom

We hung a mirror above the dresser and installed curtains (Ikea Lenda panels with the tabs removed and hung on rings). Those small details helped finish the room quickly—now the front bedroom is almost complete. There are still little things to tweak, like swapping out stock art in frames, steaming curtains, and perfecting the inlay touch-ups, but it already feels calm and airy.

img 85072 10

I love how the cooler, beachy palette works with rich, warm elements in the room. The high-contrast metal bed frame and dark curtain rods give structure, while textiles—the curtains, bedding, and rug—soften the space. Small details like spool legs on side tables, a geometric lamp base, and framed art add personality without overwhelming the serene vibe.

metal headboard in beachy blue bedroom with pine floors

The real stars are the original heart pine floors we sanded and clear-sealed and the doors we stripped back to their natural wood. Those warm, authentic finishes balance the cooler coastal colors in the room beautifully and give this beach house its character.

bed in front of window with original pine door

That solid wood knob and tiny keyhole under it—details like that make me surprisingly emotional. Finding and restoring a piece that fits both the room and its story feels really satisfying.

P.S. If you want the paint colors we used or a list of items in the beach house, we’ve compiled a source list and shared many more renovation updates and photos over the past year.

*This post contains affiliate links*