How to Seal Stenciled Plywood Floors for a Durable Finish
It’s been nearly a month since we first mentioned stenciling the floor in our sink nook. We’ve been bouncing around several projects lately — refinishing Clara’s room, working on outdoor tiling, installing a stair runner, landscaping, and beginning kitchen renovations — but the sink nook still had a few tasks to finish:
- seal the stenciled floor
- refill the closet after the floors cured, prioritizing function and storage rather than the random piles we shoved in when we moved
- update the vanity for improved function and a refreshed finish, including adding inexpensive shelves to the empty cubby on the right

To seal the floor, Sherry used a small foam roller to apply two thin, even coats of SafeCoat Acrylaq, our preferred non-toxic poly. She rolled the coats about 24 hours apart and wore a respirator because it wasn’t completely scent-free. She started in the far corner of the closet and rolled outward, then blocked the area while it cured to avoid any puppy paw prints.

The sealer has proven to be a solid protective finish — it reduced our worry about chips and spills, and I was even able to scrape off a dried stain without damaging the stencil.
After waiting about 72 hours for the sealer to fully cure, we moved on to organizing the closet. This time we approached it with intention: a dresser and mirror, plus a laundry basket used as a hamper, replaced a jumble of bins and piles. The dresser will probably move to the nursery eventually, and a new dresser will replace it when we add built-ins around our bed.

Here’s Sherry’s side of the closet:

And my side (note the shoe difference):

When we moved in this was the state of the closet — piles on the floor. Fresh paint on walls, trim, floor and ceiling, plus thoughtful organization and a couple of pieces of furniture (the dresser is a hand-me-down and the mirror was a yard sale find) made a dramatic difference.

Next up were the shelves for the vanity cubby. The build was straightforward, but we planned carefully to balance function and aesthetics:
- How to build supports for two practical shelves.
- Where to attach face boards so the new shelves would match the vanity’s look.
We sketched the design on paper and divided tasks: Sherry handled the sealing and much of the organizing while I built and stained the shelves. The staining step involved VOC-based products, so I took that on while she focused on less-fume tasks.
I started building from the floor up.

Step 1: I nailed a small scrap of wood into the vanity side and a matching piece into the baseboard on the opposite side. One side rested on the floor, the other was set back 3/4″ from the front of the vanity’s toe kick.
Step 2: That created a place to attach a plywood strip that extended the toe kick across the opening.
Step 3: Above that I nailed matching strips of 1×2″ boards (ripped in half) to support the bottom shelf. I offset them slightly from the vanity bottom to accommodate the face board thickness.

Step 4: The first shelf was cut from leftover plywood and fit so snugly it didn’t need nails.

Step 5: I added small support strips on three sides for the middle shelf after carefully measuring the center of the space. (The bottom shelf happened to rest on the baseboard so it needed no back strip.)

Step 6: The second shelf was installed from the same plywood scrap.
Step 7: To mimic the existing vanity’s look, I added a face board at the top of the opening. I nailed small scrap pieces slightly set back from the cabinet front to accept the face board.

Step 8: I installed a vertical face board against the wall, ripping a 1×3″ down to 1×2″ to match existing trim, then glued and nailed it to the supports and shelves.
Step 9: Because the vertical board consumed the original top scrap, I screwed another scrap to its back to provide an anchor for the horizontal face boards.

Step 10: The horizontal face boards, ripped to 2″ wide, were glued and nailed to the supports and shelf fronts. I had accounted for the face board thickness when placing the shelf support strips so the bottom edge aligned with the existing vanity profile.

Building the unit was the fastest part — cutting and double-checking measurements took the most time. I tried to measure twice and cut once so everything would fit snugly.

The next step was matching the new shelves to the old vanity. We wanted to keep visible wood grain while choosing a slightly richer, darker stain to complement other dark wood accents in the bedroom. We’ve had success using PolyShades on other projects, so we used a leftover can in Espresso. Before applying PolyShades, Sherry lightly sanded the existing vanity to ensure even penetration.

We brushed a leftover stain onto the new shelves first to bring them closer to the vanity color, then applied a single coat of Espresso PolyShades. One coat bridged the color gap while preserving some variation and visible wood grain; two coats would have evened the tone but made it darker than we wanted.
Before reattaching doors and drawer, we replaced the knobs with inexpensive octagon-shaped ones that complement the dark stain without competing with the patterned floor. We also added two knobs to the dummy drawer face for a balanced look, and replaced the cabinet hinges.

Here’s a reminder of the original vanity:

And where we ended up:

The dark stain does obscure some details in photos, but in person the grain reads nicely and the new shelves look original to the vanity. Because we only applied one coat of PolyShades, there’s subtle variation across the surfaces that we like. For a more uniform finish, a second coat would be recommended.

This update was very affordable for us since we used leftover plywood and stain. Our out-of-pocket costs were a 1×2″ and a 1×3″ board ($12), new knobs ($12), and two oil-rubbed bronze hinges ($6) — a total of about $30. If you need to buy plywood and stain, add roughly $30 to that estimate.
Between this project, our half bathroom refresh, and the stair makeover, we’re leaning toward higher-contrast, almost monochromatic accents in the house’s smaller nooks. That doesn’t mean we’re abandoning color — the adjacent bedroom is still bright and patterned — but we’re appreciating how darker touches can enhance each space.

Here’s a before shot from the same angle taken before we moved in:

With these changes, Phase 1 of the sink nook feels nearly complete. We’re juggling wallpaper stripping in the dining room and starting kitchen updates before the holidays, so finishing this small but meaningful project felt great. What did you tackle this weekend — building, sealing, staining, new hardware, or closet organization? Having a real place for everything after months of living out of bins makes daily life feel a little calmer.








