How We Sold Our Home For Sale By Owner and Bought a New House
To the tune of Katy Perry’s “Hot N’ Cold”… we’ve bought and we’ve sold—well, not quite, but we are moving in that direction. As of 5:57 pm yesterday we learned that the last negotiations with potential buyers on our current home went through, so our house is officially pending sale.

Because the purchase of our new house was contingent on selling this one, that contract should move forward as well. If everything continues smoothly with inspections and financing, we expect to move directly from our current home into our new house in a little over a month. We’re thrilled and a little bit giddy—think high fives, jazz hands, and the classic awkward happy dance.
We waited to share the news until the sale was certain because we didn’t want to get attached or make a premature announcement. Now that both contracts are progressing and inspections are complete, everything hinges on the lending process, which we’re optimistic about. So here we are, ready to share the update online.
We’ll publish a full breakdown soon about how we priced, marketed, and sold our home for sale by owner, but first: let’s talk about our new house. We’re borderline obsessed. We keep doodling the new address with hearts in the margins of our notebooks. It brings back the same can’t-sleep excitement we felt when we bought our current home in 2006.
The moment the front door opened and we stepped into what will become our entryway—complete with great built-ins—we just knew. I couldn’t hide my grin and probably freaked out the realtor with my obvious delight.
We ended up using a buyer’s agent after calling to see one listing; she showed us another property she thought would suit us better. Initially we were skeptical because we had dismissed that listing during a late-night search on realtor.com—why? It had a carport.

We had been set on an enclosed garage for storage, pest control, and privacy reasons, so we had weeded out any home with a carport. In retrospect that strict filter almost kept us from finding the perfect fit. We agreed to tour the house anyway, and it was a revelation. Even better: the sellers are offering a credit to convert the carport into a garage, which made the decision feel even more meant to be. The takeaway: be willing to widen your search criteria—your ideal house might be hiding behind a carport.
So, meet our future Casa Petersik. It doesn’t have a high-design exterior yet, and that’s fine—we can imagine the possibilities. While the outside reminds us a bit of our current home, the interior is larger, more flexible, and full of potential.

THE STATS:
- Age: 1960s
- House size: approximately 2,500 square feet
- Lot size: 0.75 acres (very similar to our current lot but more square than long)
- Bedrooms: 4
- Bathrooms: 3
THE PROS:
- Immediate “this is it” feeling the moment we walked in
- Open, flexible floor plan that will accommodate a growing family and a home-based business
- Three modest bedrooms plus a large master suite with ensuite bathroom and walk-in closet
- A true blank slate—so much potential for updates and DIY projects
- Large, centrally located kitchen ideal for family gatherings and future remodeling plans
- Excellent neighborhood close to family and good schools; conveniently near where we live now
- It’s a ranch-style house, which we’ve always loved for its single-level living and layout
THE CONS:
- Slightly larger than we initially expected we’d choose, though still comfortably within our budget
- Landscaping will require more attention than at our current home, which we’re ready to tackle
- It has a carport, though the seller credit to enclose it and create a garage solves that concern
- The lot feels less private than our current property, but we already have ideas to increase privacy
- We can’t think of anything else—clearly we’re smitten

We’re excited to renovate, decorate, and make this perfectly imperfect house our own. The potential is obvious and inspiring. Please keep your fingers crossed that financing continues to proceed smoothly so we can close in mid-December without surprises. Until then you’ll find us poring over paint swatches, sketching layout ideas, shopping for furnishings online, charging John’s drill batteries, decluttering, packing, and generally being unnaturally excited about moving and home improvement projects. We can’t wait to share this next chapter with you.








