How to Replace an Old Bathroom Light Fixture
We don’t often talk about our hall bathroom. In the 17 months we’ve lived here it’s only come up twice before—in posts titled “knocking down a towel bar” and “fixing the toilet.” We even borrowed the original inspiration color for our guest bedroom, so that color’s off the table for this little room and we’ve been undecided about the next step. Still, we finally made a small but noticeable lighting upgrade, which felt like a good place to start.

The old fixture wasn’t awful, just very builder-basic—long, flat, and a little too “backstage makeup counter” for our taste. With a long vanity and mirror, the extra width felt overbearing, so we kept an eye out for something with more height and less horizontal dominance—ideally a bit industrial so it wouldn’t look too delicate over the large mirror.
We browsed home improvement stores here and there, but nothing clicked. Then, about a month ago while browsing online, Sherry spotted a dark-bronze, slightly industrial fixture that felt right. It echoes other lights we’ve used in the house—the outdoorsy guest bathroom light we brought inside and the porch fixture that came with the house—so it fit the aesthetic we’ve been building.

At $60 (marked down from $100), the fixture was affordable and seemed like a solid value compared with pricier options that hadn’t excited us. We ordered it and, after a few weeks of letting it sit on the counter, finally installed it.
The installation was straightforward. First I shut off power to the whole house since our fuse box isn’t labeled well enough to trust a single switch. Then I removed all the glass shades and bulbs from the old fixture and unscrewed it from the wall. Picture me taking a few mirrored selfies in the process—thanks to the mirror’s placement, I documented more of the swap than I had planned.

Behind the fixture was a large metal mounting plate and a lot of dust and grime. Unscrewing that revealed an imprint on the wall where the old plate had sat: unpainted patches, a little rust, and some paint drips.

We tested the area with a lead paint kit we picked up months ago and were relieved when it was negative. I smoothed the rough ridges from the previous paint job with my palm sander to give our future paint a clean base; painting is on the to-do list once we decide on a new color for the whole room.

Out of the box the new fixture looked sharp—dark bronze, a little industrial, and sturdier than its price suggested. I installed the mounting bar, though the included screws didn’t fit our junction box so we had to make a quick hardware-store run. After that I connected the wires, secured the fixture, and reattached the metal shades and bulbs.



The two 100-watt-equivalent bulbs provide more than enough light for the small bathroom, and the darker finish helps balance the room’s dark accent tile. The fixture’s matte, slightly distressed finish reads as authentic rather than cheaply made; the small worn areas give it character and make it feel a little like an heirloom, even though we just bought it off a sale page.

We like that the new light fills the vertical space above the mirror better than the old, wider fixture did, creating more visual balance with the tall shower curtain on the opposite side of the room. Quality-wise it punches above its price: not flimsy, with a rich dark finish that feels intentional.

The old fixture is already dropped off at our local Habitat ReStore, so the swap is complete. We still have a long list of small bathroom updates—framing the mirror, picking a paint color, repainting the vanity, swapping hardware, treating the window, and hanging art—but this new vanity lighting makes the room feel a step closer to the vision we have for it. Small upgrades like this are often the momentum we need to tackle the next jobs.

What have you chosen for your bathroom—art, lighting, mirrors, or paint colors? Do you ever feel nervous ordering a light without seeing it in person? We were a little anxious clicking “buy,” but happy we took the chance: this vanity light has already improved the look and feel of our hall bathroom and should serve well through the next set of updates.








