How Should Wendy Handle Her Dilemma? Share Your Ideas
We’re in the middle of a group brainstorming session and Wendy would love your suggestions for her home’s exterior. She and her family are ready to tackle a major front-of-house refresh and are looking for color ideas that will update the look without clashing with their HOA rules. Here’s her note:
We’ve lived in our two-story brick house for about four years. The trim is peeling and desperately needs repainting, but we can’t decide on a color. The current off-white feels dull and our style is not especially traditional, even though the house is. We’re allowed limited changes by our HOA, but I’d like to add some personality—maybe a bright front door? The one complication is that our brick tends toward orange rather than red. I’m not ready to paint the brick, so I’d love suggestions for door, shutter, and trim colors that work with the warm brick tone. Thanks! – Wendy (Mike, Lucas, and Jackson)
After studying the photo, I experimented in Photoshop with several directions that keep the brick as-is while giving the house more curb appeal. Below are three distinct approaches and some complementary styling ideas—all meant to be HOA-friendly and achievable without painting the brick itself.
- Crisp classic contrast: Replace the tired off-white trim with clean white to brighten the façade and modernize the look. A glossy red front door can surprisingly reduce the perceived orange of the brick by contrast—think a bold, classic red in a semi-gloss finish. Add seasonal plantings like red tulips or potted red blooms to reinforce the door color without permanent changes.
- Polished details: Install oversized, substantial porch lanterns to anchor the entry and add curb weight. Use a prominent, scripty metal house number centered above the portico for a charming focal point. Flank the door with matching planters and a pair of topiaries or evergreen pots for year-round structure.
- Neutral-to-warm base: Paint the porch steps a neutral mocha to neutralize any leftover reddish tones at ground level and create a subtle, grounded transition from the sidewalk to the entry.

- Deep navy option: For a bolder but very handsome look, choose a rich navy for the door—colors like Regatta or Hale Navy read as sophisticated and slightly unexpected against warm brick. Paint shutters a deep charcoal-navy a few shades darker than the door so they provide depth without looking like stark black. Add simple, clean-lined planters and hanging baskets for softness and texture.

- Fresh green option: If you want a lively, approachable choice, try a fresh spring green or chartreuse door that taps into the surrounding landscape. With white trim and shutters, a green door reads modern and friendly without overwhelming the orange brick. Use topiaries or climbing greenery around porch columns to visually tie the color to the garden.

- Accessories and planting ideas: Consider adding window boxes for seasonal color, a distinguished vintage-style doorknocker and solid, well-proportioned hardware, and balanced porch lighting. Climbing vines or trained plants can soften columns and add vertical green interest—ask your local nursery for suitable species that won’t damage brick or wood.
- Other palette combinations to consider: plum door with charcoal shutters and white trim; robin’s egg blue door with navy shutters and white trim; or deep teal for a moody, modern look. Each choice can be enhanced by complementary outdoor lighting and well-chosen pots.

Clara’s imaginative idea—purple bushes and blue bricks—reminds us it’s fun to push boundaries, even if the final plan has to be more practical. Which direction do you prefer for Wendy: Team Red, Team Navy, Team Green, or something entirely different? Share your favorite combinations, lighting ideas, or hardware suggestions to help her narrow it down.
If you have a tricky spot in your own home you’d like help with, please send at least three photos, a simple floor plan sketch, and a short description to [email protected]. Include what’s stumping you and any constraints like HOA rules so suggestions can be tailored to your situation.








