Objectales

Popular

Splurge vs Save: What to Spend On and When

featured 63171

We get asked this question all the time: when should you splurge and when should you save during a home renovation? The short answer is: it depends. We sometimes overspend on one item because it’s uniquely right for us, and save on another by choosing a perfectly good budget option or doing it ourselves. Below is a clear breakdown of our approach, examples from our own house, and a few guiding questions that help us decide.

img 63171 1

The words “splurge” and “save” mean different things to different people. For one person, a splurge might be a full $50k kitchen renovation; for another it could be buying higher-quality hardwood and installing it yourself. One person’s “save” could mean strictly using what they already own or buying all secondhand, while another’s could include carefully chosen pieces from big-box stores. With that context, here’s a breakdown of what we’ve splurged on and where we’ve saved so far.

So far in our new house, we’ve splurged on:

  • Hardwood floors throughout the second floor
  • An upgraded, slate-like roof
  • An extensive sunroom renovation, including tile and ceiling work
  • Hiring a professional to level the yard
  • Upgraded doorknobs rather than spray-painting the old hardware
  • Two Nest thermostats to control separate systems on each floor
  • Higher-end furnishings and built-ins in select rooms
  • Extra-thick crown molding in key rooms
  • Upgraded light fixtures in the kitchen and foyer
  • A quality Dash & Albert stair runner
  • Privacy trees planted in the backyard
  • Premium laundry appliances with extra features

img 63171 2

Some items sit in a gray area between splurge and save. For example, a Restoration Hardware table we bought at a deep discount felt like a splurge in terms of quality but a save in terms of price. Likewise, we invested in a nicer stair runner but installed it ourselves. These hybrid choices let us balance cost with long-term value.

So far we’ve saved on:

  • Painting walls, ceilings, trim, and baseboards ourselves
  • Refreshing grout in the foyer for very little cost
  • Rejuvenating existing downstairs wood floors with wax rather than replacing them
  • Thrifted or secondhand finds—four kitchen chairs for a bargain
  • Painting existing interior doors instead of installing new ones
  • Removing wallpaper from multiple rooms ourselves
  • Stripping, resealing, and staining the deck
  • Phase-one updates in several rooms: updating vanities, removing old carpeting, stenciling floors, painting and staining cabinets, adding inexpensive shelving, and swapping out bulky appliances for simpler solutions
  • DIY closet and organization projects (pantry, toy closet, etc.)
  • Playful kids’ room updates like painted closet doors, a canopy, and a feature wall

img 63171 3

Some things funded larger splurges—like a home warranty that covered a new furnace or money returned at closing that was used on a roof. Our strategy is to invest in permanent, long-term solutions where it matters, while making affordable interim updates in spaces we plan to renovate down the road. For example, we’ll live with inexpensive kitchen or bathroom fixes now so we don’t pour money into a space we’ll redo later, whereas a sunroom or a roof is something we wanted to do right from the start.

img 63171 6

Below are a few potential future plans—some we expect to splurge on, and others we plan to tackle ourselves.

Possible future splurges:

  • New kitchen appliances and a future gas range
  • Adding a gas insert to the living room fireplace
  • More exterior updates and privacy plantings
  • Upgraded furnishings, lighting, and window treatments over time
  • Thoughtful full bathroom and kitchen renovations when we’re ready
  • Built-in cabinetry for the office and hallway niches
  • Converting kitchen windows to French doors leading to the deck
  • Finishing an unfinished storage room as a bunk/media room for older kids

Possible future saves (DIY or budget-focused):

  • Removing non-load-bearing walls ourselves
  • Attempting big installs ourselves when practical (heated tile, etc.)
  • Building custom cabinetry in targeted spots
  • Handling landscaping tasks like transplanting and mulching
  • Continuing cosmetic updates—painting trim, walls, and ceilings
  • Investing in energy-efficiency measures gradually (LEDs, insulation)
  • Reusing old kitchen cabinets in the garage for workshop storage

img 63171 7

If you’re uncertain whether to splurge or save, ask yourself these four practical questions before deciding.

#1. How long will you live with it? Spend more on items that will last for decades—floors, roofs, high-quality windows. For temporary or interim solutions in rooms you’ll remodel soon, choose inexpensive, effective fixes like paint, hardware swaps, or cosmetic changes.

img 63171 9

#2. How much will it affect your daily life? If a feature will meaningfully improve daily comfort or convenience—like a smart thermostat, a comfortable tub you’ll use, or a reliable oven—it can be worth splurging. Choose upgrades that you will actually use often.

img 63171 10

#3. How much wear will it take? High-traffic, heavily used items deserve higher quality. A sturdy table, dependable appliances, or a well-built sofa are worth investing in; cheap versions may need replacing sooner and cost more over time. That said, thorough research can help you find budget pieces that punch above their weight.

img 63171 11

#4. Does the visual impact depend on this choice? If one item defines the look of the room—a dramatic light fixture, full-length curtains, or a unique coffee table—splurge on that piece and save elsewhere. Small visual anchors often make the biggest difference in achieving your desired style.

That’s our splurge vs. save philosophy in a nutshell. We try to strike a balance: invest in things that matter long-term and save on projects we can do ourselves or replace easily. What patterns have you noticed in your own projects—where you splurge and where you cut corners? Often mixing a few well-chosen splurges with budget-friendly wins creates the best overall result.

img 63171 8